Mike's Pizzeria — Restaurant in Homestead

I wish I could leave half a star.... what terrible customer service and pizza. We ordered a pizza and the lady over the phone seem confused so I repeated the order and asked her to repeat back to me. Seemed correct. WRONG. My husband got there and the pizza was not what we ordered. They told him they didn’t do refunds (go figure) so basically we had to wait for another pizza. The lady told him it would just be 30 minutes . After 30 minutes my husband noticed they were just putting the new pizza into the oven. When my husband asked the waitress if that was our pizza she said, “yes”. My husband told her he had already been there an extra 30 minutes like she said it would take. The pizza maker (owner I’m assuming) told him he had to wait because it was busy and there were other orders in front of his. They should have made our new pizza a priority since they messed up the first pizza. They offered him free dessert or half off our next order. He took the half off deal. Don’t think we will be using that deal though because the pizza was OK. Not to mention, We ordered a dozen garlic “rolls” over the phone. The waitress said they only had half a dozen because they were so busy and they needed to “bake” more. When we opened up the garlic “rolls” they were cold (obviously, because they had been sitting there an hour) and they were not rolls. They were slices of a baguette with olive oil and some garlic on only some of the slices. What a joke. Save the headache and order some good pizza and hot fresh garlic rolls from...

First time & LAST TIME ever ordering here today. For one I was put on hold constantly, without letting me know. Then transferred to another person , my order was bein taken an payment then out of nowhere hold music an 2 min later someone else gets on the line like if I just called in smh ….. veeeeeery frustrating when you have a house of 5 to feeed. No one really spoke English so I had to repeat numbers over 3 times … Then as I finished my order the woman repeated in , but when I FINALLY GOT MY FOOD . It’s NOT What I asked for …. I asked for buffalo chicken pizza with blue cheese drizzled on top .. she said “ok blue cheese on it ok” Yes an blue cheese for the order of hot wings … pizza came with just dry looking chicken an some over cooked hot sauce on it …. Was highly disappointed ,for a $54 pizza an $12 wings that couldn’t even have a side of blue cheese ….Not only that when I finally opened my soda it all blew up on my kitchen table … like if someone shook it up … smh now after trying to feed my kids I’m in rushing to stop volcano of soda from going on their plates … very bad experience .. an they hung up when I called about it & said I didn’t pay for the blue cheese (a different guy ) smh they didn’t do anything to make me want to order from there again ..sucks when you can’t enjoy your food like you Pay to do … I wish they had better...

Three-Star Review:

I recently visited this pizzeria and had an overall decent experience. The staff was friendly and attentive, ensuring that our orders were correct, though they didn't go out of their way to provide any extra service.

The pizza itself was just okay, but I was pleasantly surprised by the pasta and garlic bread, both of which were quite good. The chicken wings were also satisfactory, though nothing to rave about.

However, I must mention my disappointment with the desserts. I ordered a red velvet cake that unfortunately had fuzzy mold on it. The staff explained that the desserts are supplied by a vendor, which I believed due to the label "Korilyn Sweets." They mentioned they would no longer be using this vendor, which I think is a good decision.

Overall, the restaurant is fine, but I wouldn’t make a special trip for it. If I happen to be in the area, I might stop by for a slice, but it wouldn’t be my first choice...