Jerry’s Custard — Restaurant in Indiana Township

Super excited that this new custard place opened up near me. Very few custard places in this general area.

So I've gone two times and really enjoyed the custard each time. I tried several flavors: cookie monster, raspberry cheesecake, and salted caramel cheesecake. All of them were really tasty. I love how soft and creamy the custard is. It even retains that softness when you buy a quart and put it in your freezer. Somehow I could easily scoop it out immediately with a regular spoon and it's never hard like ice cream, which I really appreciate. I love soft custard.

The flavors change daily and get posted on their social media. They offer scoops, milkshakes, floats, and more. I was really intrigued by the idea of an ice cream flight with 6 flavors, but that might be too much for me.

The waffle cone is ridiculously large. If you want to go into an ice cream coma, get a waffle cone. One scoop is so large, but two scoops could drown you. 😂 I don't think I'd ever go for three scoops.

They also have a nice seating area. The parking seems a little limited and awkwardly located along a busy road. Otherwise, it's a great spot...

I was excited to visit this place because there aren't many good local ice cream options. The small menu at the storefront was okay, but the available choices need to be well-made. Unfortunately, the custard was disappointing, especially compared to Glen’s Custard, Emmerling’s, and Bruster’s, which are other nearby options.

The texture was icy and it seemed more watery than creamy. Perhaps the saturated fat content is too low, or the freezing process is too slow.

The flavors also seemed weak. I would compare the texture and flavor to a fudge pop or Millie’s (which isn’t a compliment).

I hope they can improve the quality because I would like to support them. They don't have to be as good as Salt & Straw or Jeni’s, but they...

Jerry's is a cute, new custard stand. The staff were friendly and asked if there were other flavors I would like to taste. I tried black raspberry and orange dream with both being good flavors. The consistency of the custard was not quite on point - a bit icy and gummy, but I loved the waffle cone! It tasted fresh and was huge for a small. Nice outdoor area to enjoy your custard. Downside, very limited parking that backs into...