Petrillo's Pizza Pub & Grill — Restaurant in Madison

Ordered pizza from here it was bland and the crust was hard and chewy not crunchy .., Decided to give it a try again months later asked them if they put oregano on their pizza they said no so I requested they lightly sprinkle our pizza with oregano and have it baked in. I specifically said lightly sprinkled because the pizza really needs flavor. Well they basically put piles of oregano on the pizza. It was ridiculous. Obviously they were mad because I asked them if they would slightly sprinkle oregano and it was covered in oregano. I will never order pizza from here again. The amount of oregano was ridiculous and Not lightly sprinkled and we only ordered pizza from here because they delivered will not order from here again Bradley And Wall is way better so is Amatos. I grew up in the Italian section and I know what a good pizza supposed to have back in the 60s. It was really good pizza and really expensive. Good cheese and let me tell you cheese makes the pizza specially if you get a white pie....

I used to love Petrillo's I swore by them, telling my friends that they have the best pizza around. Unfortunately, they didn't like it. I told them that can't be right. Not Petrillo's, but the last two times have left me very disappointed. I am now going to look for a new pizza place to eat. Tonight was the last straw..they take the order, but when I receive it it's not what I ordered. Like tonight..it was light sauce..they were heavy on the sauce, and as for the other one it was extra cheese and there was regular amount of cheese on it. The crust was all wrong as it was way too thin. I like a thicker crust. The last time the crust was all uneven. Really thick in some parts and really thin in others. Either they have new employees or they changed hands and not told anyone. That's how different it's been the last...

WARNING: Petrillos has recently sold! As a result, the food quality has significantly gone into a downward spiral! Too bad the previous owners (Eddy and Clem) did not include a name change in their selling agreement because the Petrillo name is being negatively effected. We have been long standing customers with especially enjoying their pizzas. Unfortunately, the new owners DO NOT know how to make pizza. It was rock hard and paper thin, so much so that you could lift the entire pie with a couple of fingers and it all stayed together...My husband frisbeed it into the woods. They were very nice in handling the complaint and made another for us, but unfortunately, the 2nd one was not much better. Have taken their # out of my list of...