New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream — Restaurant in Marlboro Township

I recently visited New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream, and I have to highlight what made my experience truly exceptional: Nathan. From the moment I walked in, Nathan’s warm smile and infectious enthusiasm set the stage for an outstanding visit.

Nathan’s knowledge of the ice cream flavors at New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream was truly impressive. He took the time to explain each option in detail and made thoughtful recommendations based on my preferences. His passion for the shop and its offerings was evident, and his suggestions led me to some of the best flavors I’ve ever had.

What really set Nathan apart was his meticulous attention to detail. He prepared my ice cream with such care, ensuring every scoop was perfectly measured and every topping was added just right. His dedication to creating a perfect ice cream experience was clear in the quality of the final product.

In addition to his exceptional service, Nathan’s humility and kindness were evident when he personally paid for my ice cream. This generous gesture went above and beyond what I expected and truly highlighted his remarkable character.

If Nathan were ever to leave New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream, it would be a significant loss. His exceptional service, personal touch, and humility have set a high standard for customer experience. His departure would be deeply felt by loyal customers like myself.

Nathan’s contributions have turned my visits to New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream into delightful experiences I’ll remember fondly. Thanks to him, I am now an even more loyal customer. If you’re looking for an unparalleled ice cream experience, Nathan is the person to see!

Thank you, Nathan, for making my visit so special. Your exceptional service and generosity are truly...

I recently had the pleasure of being served by Nathan at New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream, and I was deeply impressed by his genuine humility and kindness. Nathan is a truly down-to-earth individual who embodies the spirit of exceptional customer service with a remarkable touch of generosity.

Nathan’s humble nature was evident from the moment I interacted with him. Despite his extensive knowledge of the ice cream menu and his evident skill in crafting the perfect treat, he remained modest and focused entirely on making sure each customer had a great experience. His genuine approach made me feel valued and appreciated throughout my visit.

What truly set Nathan apart was a heartwarming gesture that demonstrated his extraordinary kindness. I witnessed him pay for the ice cream of a single mother and her child, a simple yet profoundly impactful act of generosity. This thoughtful gesture not only brightened their day but also highlighted Nathan’s remarkable character. His willingness to help others, without seeking recognition or reward, speaks volumes about his humility and compassion.

Nathan’s actions have turned an ordinary visit to New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream into something special. His blend of modesty, warmth, and genuine care for others sets a high standard for customer service. If you’re looking for an experience that goes beyond just great ice cream, Nathan’s exceptional service and humble spirit make him a standout choice.

Thank you, Nathan, for making my visit so memorable. Your humility and kindness are truly appreciated and make you a remarkable part of the New Baltimore Homemade...

The ice cream is always good; better than anything in the area. Whenever at one of the area parks for a walk, hike or kayak, this is a must stop. Follow their social media for the most up-to-date flavors between their "44" and "619" locations. If the peach ice cream is available be sure to try it. If this is a place that you have frequented for years and it's been a while you may want to "size-up" your ice cream. The portions seem smaller, but still generous and a good value for the quality you receive.

That said, my concern for supporting here right now is not the business itself, but the patrons and customers. Little to no customers follow what the business has done to help direct social distancing to help keep their employees and customers safe and less susceptible. They have orange cones with signs to guide the line and flow of customers spaced out for proper distancing. There are also only two picnic tables to discourage congregating of people. Anytime I have been there this year, (which has been several) no one has followed the cones, and people still congregate in large groups, do not wear masks, and are not socially distancing while in line. If you, or you know someone who is immunocompromised or just do not feel safe, message them on social media and you make arrangements to pick up a quart and they will bring it out to you. Which is incredibly accommodating for...