Goodfella's Pizza, Pasta and Subs — Restaurant in Ocean Breeze

So happy Goodfellas took over from the previous pizza place here as it is very close to my home. When we first moved to FL four years ago we rented in Ft. Pierce for a few months and Goodfellas was our go-to for pizza up there. The owners of the previous Big Apple pizza at this location were nasty and unfriendly so we stopped going there all together and then another lady took over the operation a year or two ago but the food wasn't very good. Goodfellas pizza is delicious and the crust actually has flavor. Try the Italian Delight Pizza (pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, peppers, black olives and extra cheese). Also, thrilled that they carry stuffed rolls -- haven't been able to find them since I moved down here. The sausage & peppers roll is so good! They also have other varieties (chicken parm, chicken broccoli, steak & cheese, meatball parm, etc.) that are so good and they come with a side of sauce. There is wine & beer available as well.

Mostly though, the staff is super nice. Ellena was at the front last night when I went in and she couldn't be nicer or more accommodating. In fact, all of the staff in the back were friendly and welcoming. That makes a big difference when there are so many pizza places around here to choose from. ...

Tonight we placed our order w/JT who answered the phone, he was very professional, patient, kind n caring as he took his time to suggest menu options since we didn’t have one n were ordering delivery. He didn’t rush us n allowed us to ask questions n request different dishes n even offered to try n make us something not even on their menu when he found out it was a favorite dish of mine.

The food arrived on time n was nice n hot not to mention delicious …and Brianna was our deliver driver…She was smiling holding our food when we opened the door n so polite.

We enjoyed trying the shrimp scampi lasagna garlic rolls salad meatballs n the mushrooms.

Both my teenager and toddler who can be very picky eaters really enjoyed the dinner as did I!!!

I called back n personally thanking the team for their service and hospitality. Thanking them for the delicious food!!!

Customer service is rare today n this team went above n beyond to make us want to make this our first choice when we order neighborhood delivery.

Highly recommend this place!!! The owner must take great care of his staff for them to treat his customers so well....

I love you all at Goodfellas and, was so excited to see you open in Jensen Beach but, yesterday on Monday myself and, my lady ordered Togo and, we picked it up tipped the girl $10.00 and paid the bill the Italian Feast was just what we wanted greasy cheesy food.... I had a Cheese Steak Sub and, it was just ok very low on the toppings especially the tomatoes on the top 4 tiny tomato slices (the first thing you see when you open up the sub) then the Goodfellas salad is advertised with artichoke hearts and, there was not a single artichoke heart on the salad..... No worries I still love you guys and, will most likely continue to do business with you but, let's step it up a notch, if you are going to put a tiny amount of meat on your subs, then pile on the toppings for a nice presentation, if you ran out of artichoke hearts just let me know and don't charge me for them, keep the greasy cheesy fried stuff coming sometimes we all need some of that. Thank You...