Orr Valley Creamery — Restaurant in Orrville

I have the most incredible experiences at Orr Valley Creamery in Orrville! From the moment I walk in, I am always greeted by the most friendly and welcoming staff. A special shout-out to Kristine and Marilyn, the hardest working and most pleasant people you will ever meet! The Sarasota Concrete, a frozen custard that you can mix-in your favorite goodies, is out of this world and always tastes incredibly fresh because it is made in-house. I especially love the unique and creative hard ice cream flavors. My personal favorites are Peppy's Puppy Chow, named after a special dog Peppy (RIP) and Dismal Swamp, named after what was once known as Dismal Swamp Rd (now called Burton City Rd) and the swamp lands southeast of Orrville. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, with family-friendly 50's old time rock 'n roll music playing in the background. There is plenty of seating, both inside and outside, to enjoy your ice cream with friends or family. When it is cooler in the evenings, be sure to take the kids to the back area where they can play on the turf while you sit around the fire pit. Overall, I highly recommend this ice cream shop to anyone looking for a delicious and memorable experience. It's definitely worth the drive and a must-visit for any ice...

The ice cream is, of course, AMAZING, but that's kinda it. I got their coney dogs the other day, and the chili sauce was bland. Plus, for one coney dog, you're paying almost 8 dollars for a hot dog and bland chili sauce. My sons grilled cheese was burnt and very small. It was actually kind of disappointing. I got a kids' meal, 2 coney dogs, and I paid almost 35 dollars. It didn't fill us up, and my son couldn't eat his grilled cheese because it was so burnt. I recommend this place for their milkshakes and ice cream, but that's it. I don't see this place lasting if flavor doesn't get introduced into the food, portion sizes don't get bigger or prices come down...

Orr Valley is one of our FAVORITE Places to take our family and friends to grab a bite to eat, or grab some delicious ice cream!! Their staff is always ready and willing to help with any and all of our question and our needs! We always have a wonderful experience! Now to RAVE about my Two FAVORITE members of the Orr Valley Team that are truly amazing- Kris and Marilyn!!! You two are AMAZING! Not only do you spoil our daughter with love and kindness every time we enter the property, but you both radiate kindness. You can truly tell your love for people is never ending. You both make the experience of Orr Valley!!! We Love...