Brooklyn's Pizza — Restaurant in Penn Township

My wife's favorite overall pizza, and my favorite local football pizza (don't know what football pizza is? Google one bite pizza reviews with El Prez).

The thing about pizza is, that they are like snowflakes and all different. Folks are always trying to figure out who is the "best" but the reality is that pizza that you love is the "best for you". That's why there are so many out there. But you can't go wrong with Brooklyn's and I'm SOOO glad that they are back. We usually order the XL 3-topping with pepperoni and half mushroom half sausage because that magically appeases everyone in the house. The reason that I mention it is that I find sausage on pizza to be very hit or miss and Brooklyn's hits.

Recently got a steak sub as well and I'll be ordering it again. Real steak, great roll...worth a try.

Finally, the owners and the workers are super nice and friendly and always make you feel welcome when you stop to pick up. I mention this because, let's be honest, we've had places in PT that haven't always given us that and it's worth noting.

Sorry that I forgot to take a pic, I'll update the next time that we order...which will be soon. ...

Brooklyn’s Pizza is hands down the king of the local pizza scene. From the first bite, you know you’re not just eating pizza—you’re experiencing a handcrafted masterpiece. The crust? Perfect every time. Golden, crispy on the outside, soft on the inside, and never soggy. It’s the kind of base that holds everything together with pride.

The cheese is next level. Rich, melty, and full of flavor—like it was aged in heaven and pulled straight from a food lover’s dream. It’s got that perfect stretch and just enough salt to hit the taste buds with precision.

Toppings? Insanely fresh. Every ingredient feels hand-picked and placed with care. From spicy pepperoni to garden-fresh veggies, it’s not just pizza—it’s art. And don’t even get me started on the sauce. It’s flawlessly distributed, never overpowering, but always there, bringing balance to every bite.

I’ve never met a single person who doesn’t love Brooklyn’s. And if you haven’t tried it yet—seriously, what are you doing with your life? Stop reading. Go order it....

Poor quality service. First and last time I order from here. I placed an order for delivery, XL pepperoni. $19 and some change. The driver shows up. I hand him $25. He then asks if I want change back. That's pretty rude to ask, (give me my change and I'll decide) they don't do that at a restaurant. So I give the driver 5 bucks for a tip, walk inside open the box and the pizza is folded in half. I take it to the store explain my issues with the food and driver. Then the owner Mother F*"@s me calls me and calls me a smart a#&. I tell him just give me my money back, he hands me 20 bucks then follows me out of the store to my vehicle like he's going to jump me. I actually had to turn around and warn him that he was approaching me in a threatening manner.

With drivers like than and a threatening owner I dont think this place will be around...