Plumsted Grill - reviews,open hours,photo spots, things to do | WanderBoat AI Trip Planner

First time ever being at this restaurant and I must say I'm impressed. I'm not from this area, but I wish I was because I loved the food I had. I. From the south and I was a little concerned on the price of the meals. But when I realized that amount of food I was going to receive I must say its totally worth the price. I ordered the chicken and shrimp in their Jack Daniel's sause. I assumed per the menu that I was just going to get meat with broccoli and mushrooms. But when I realized I was getting a side salad and adding the rice to the main course I was excited. I barely was able to eat half of the main course after my salad and two pieces of bread. I was a little disappointed in the salad. Didn't have much on it. But again the main course made up for it. I know that my group had issues with the waitress. She supposedly rolled her eyes and grunted when they asked to separate our bill while I was in the bathroom. We did have a big party. However, I wasn't there to see it. But our waitress was professional and very helpful in my opinion. Overall great food and service. Would highly recommend to visitors of the area. Would eat here everyday if I could afford it.

R BR B

00

Just awful. Went based on good reviews but i dont know how this place has any good reviews. The service was terrible. Our waitress didnt seem to want to be there at all and wasnt friendly. The cajun tuna bites were disgustingly over salted they werent really edible. My husband got a salmon special topped with crab meat and bernaise sauce and it was full of shell pieces in the crab. His garlic mashed potatoes didnt taste garlicy and tasted boxed. Our 2 friends who were with us got burgers they said were dry and didnt taste good (they didnt finish them). I got the chicken champagne which tasted fine but was just a generic cream sauce with really mushy asparagus. Didn't taste like champagne cream sauce at all but halfway in i found a dark black hair in my food and had to stop eating. The only thing good here was the bread at the table and the fries. The waitress was rushing us the entire time and was not friendly. She came with boxes before even asking if we were done and was putting them on the table without asking. She put one box on top of my friend's food. When i told her i didn't want to box mine because i found a hair on it she asked me what color it was......but she did take the meal off our bill which was appreciated. All in all it was not a good experience and we wont be going back.

Cheryl BruderCheryl Bruder

00

Came into this place after reading the reviews while on a family trip in NJ. Love this places Atmosphere! The cabin feeling makes you feel like your home. I went on a Thursday at 6 pm and it was packed! Surprisingly we put to a table instantly! The waitress was super nice and even gave us some recommendations. I ended up getting the cabin burger. It's a very different place however. The reason I'm saying that is because you have to literally assemble your burger/sandwich. You have to choose if you want lettuce and if you want cheese you have to ask for it lol. The salad was great! The bread was super fluffy. I have no idea how they do it but they made the outside crunchy and the inside soft and fluffy! This is when it all went downhill... We waited 1 hour for food that wasn't cooked to what we told them. I told them CRISPY BACON I get a soggy wet 3 pieces of it on my perfectly cooked burger.. How are you gonna put disgusting bacon on a perfect medium burger when the customer told you they wanted the bacon WELL COOKED AND CRISPY. The fries taste like plastic and they aren't good even with ketchup. Overall I would come back here but really make sure that the bacon is cooked.

mason putnammason putnam

00

Hands down the worst experience I have ever had with the Plumsted Grill. Server MIA for majority of the time, once seated had to ask staff for menus. Ordered a burger and was served it on white bread. At least tell the customer you don't have buns so I can order something else instead of apologizing as you put it on table. This is basic food service... I'm also glad my table of four made it through the night with one round of drinks because we were never asked or offered refills. Took 20 minutes to get the check and apparently it's restaurant policy that customers need to ask for split checks but I didn't see that written any where; we weren't told that at all when we were initially seated or when ordering. When my wife walked inside to ask for the manager, our server was talking sh!t about our table. We were polite and patient until the very end when we just wanted to pay and leave but couldn't get a check. Thanks for the poor service, I won't be coming back. Good luck to anyone else dining here!

MüllerMüller

00

Been to this place 3 times over the last 2 years or so and each time it gets worse. I don't know how it has over 4 stars. I guess if you are just looking for a beer it's ok. Our server Doreen was the best part of the meal. I only gave service 3 stars because the kid at the hostess stand has an attitude problem. Ordered Potato skins for an app with the bacon on the side . They went back the first time because cheese was like rubber and wasn't even fully melted. We didn't finish them, enough said on that. Wife ordered steak sandwich which was so so and I had Pastrami RUEBEN. My fault for not fully reading the menu but who puts coleslaw on a RUEBEN. In my 52 years I have never had coleslaw on a RUEBEN. Maybe a SLOPPY JOE. The little bit of pastrami on the bread was tasteless and the top pieces were like eating jerky. Today they sold me $54 worth of insurance , Insuring I will never be back.

Kenneth HenryKenneth Henry

00

When you’re looking to meet up for some grub with your work palls or just happen to be rolling through Cream Ridge New Jersey the Plumstead bar and Grill is a nice stop. Creative, quick witted, and clever staff with the service to match. Tons on tap with bartenders to match. Overall good spot to hang out and grab a sip and dip.

Jeremy A. HillJeremy A. Hill

00