Red Star II Pizza — Restaurant in Plumsted Township

This place has horrible service. The first time we ordered pizza they gave us the complete wrong order but made it up by replacing it so we decided to give than another chace.. so we went there today to get dinner and let me tell you they have HORRIBLE customer service. We left without eating. We walked in just to order slices of pizza and say there for like 10 minutes while they just answered phones. First of all it is rude to keep answering phone when you have unhelped customers in person but it is also rude to not at least acknowledge the customers that are there. They literally didn't say a word to us while we waiting. The least that they could do would be to say hello welcome to Red Star.. we will be right with you. It's only the curious thing to do. Wont...

Stopped here for the first time tonight after moving to the area from Louisiana last week, ordered the medium calzone with garlic and steak and 6 hot wings for about 20 bucks

They were busy when I got there, Took about 20 minutes for my order to be ready which is good considering what it could be. The food was awesome, smelled amazing and was very flavorful, the crust to me was a perfect balance of crunchy and chewy. Wings were meaty and crispy. Will definitely be back but to order less food as a quarter of the calzone and a few wings were more then enough...

The pizza is great! If you are in the area and are in the mood for pizza, you will not regret choosing this pizzeria.

However, there is something extra that needs to be noted. This note is not related to the pizza itself, but rather the pizza place. During the night, the sign for the pizza place is not lit up, making it difficult to spot where exactly the pizza place is. If you are coming to this place at night, make sure to pay extra attention, else you might miss the...