Johnny's Pizza — Restaurant in Prospect Park

Before I type this to let the people looking at this review know that I order catering every week from them and it’s amazing

And If you’re in Prospect Park and craving great pizza, Johnny’s Pizza is a must-visit spot. This place delivers exactly what you want from a neighborhood pizzeria — delicious food, friendly service, and prices that are hard to beat.

The pizza at Johnny’s is consistently fresh, with a perfectly crisp crust, gooey cheese, and just the right balance of sauce. Whether you’re grabbing a plain slice or trying one of their specialty pies, the flavor always hits the mark. It’s that classic New York-style pizza you dream about.

What really sets Johnny’s apart, though, is the staff. The employees are incredibly welcoming, respectful, and handle every order with care — even during the busiest hours. You can tell they take pride in what they do, and that makes all the difference.

As for the prices? Honestly, it’s one of the best deals around. While other pizza spots nearby have bumped up their prices, Johnny’s keeps things affordable without cutting corners on quality. It’s great food at a price that doesn’t leave your wallet empty.

Overall, Johnny’s Pizza is a local gem the kind of place you’ll keep coming back to. Great pizza, great people, great prices. What more could...

This is some of the BEST Italian food I have had, and I’m from North New Jersey, the capital of Italian food, so that’s saying something!

I have ordered from Johnny’s Pizza three times in the past month, and I have a rule about only being allowed to order out rarely during this pandemic, but the food is SO. GOOD.

We always get a 16in pie with eggplant, mushrooms, and spinach. Antipasto, and eggplant parm dinner. Seriously top two of The Best eggplant parm I have ever had. It’s just perfect. The eggplant is thin and soft, delicious tomato sauce, and so cheesy. The pizza is also top notch. Some of the best.

Their customer service is also great. Whenever I call they’re super friendly, and delivery guys are awesome. They always, always follow my directions for no contact and leave the food outside. They’ll call to alert or one knocks and then walks away to wave goodbye. They’re all around a great business that I will miss when I’m not...

I heard of this pizza place located here from a family friend, and since I was in the area, I decided to give it a try. From the moment that I walked in that door, I was warmly greeted by the behind-the-counter staff, and given so many options by the menu. The young man named Karanveer working behind the counter was excellent, he was very patient and informative throughout the ordering process. I ordered the house special pizza with an extra thin and crispy crust, as well as some garlic knots. My instructions were followed perfectly, and my pizza came out thin and golden brown. The knots were crispy and fluffy, and the pizza flavors were balanced perfectly. I know this seems like an exaggerated review of what appears to be just another pizzeria, but the quality, service and food from this establishment is worth it. I’ll definitely be coming back...