Mama Stortini's Restaurant & Bar - reviews,open hours,photo spots, things to do | WanderBoat AI Trip Planner

My husband & I decided to make this a date night, upon arrival we were greeted within minuets, it was after all a Saturday night & they were a bit busy. After a shot wait we were seated at a kind of awkward table, but it was still nice. Our server named Sam, who was very pleasant, clean & professional, took our drink & appetizer order & let us know he would be back with a bread plate which is some house made marinara & a French baguette. The marinara is amazing, the bread is a little bland, I wish they also served it with an herb butter, but that's okay. Then came our appetizers, I had French onion soup, no joke the best I've had in a very long time & most defiantly the best in Pierce county. My husband had Chorizo stuffed mushrooms, he said they were great! For our main course, he had the Chicken Parmesan that is served with an amazing tomatoes sauce on a bed of spaghetti, breaded in a nice savory crust, he said it was really good. I had the Fettuccine alfredo, again another knock it out of the park dish. The sauce was so creamy, you could taste all the flavors, rich butter, plenty of garlic but not to much. Oh so good. The place is clean, pretty & has all the amenities one could ask for. We lucked out & got there at happy hour!! Whoot. lol Clean nice ladies room, nice bar & Sam was as attentive as he could be with how busy he was. He was running. Over all I would recommend this place for sure, I want to go back just for another bowl of soup lol Sorry about the pictures, new camera that I don't know how to use yet. Ugh. Well I hope this review helps someone. Have a nice day. OH & they deliver for events & have wifi

IRcuteIRcute

00

Well the food was pretty good. Honestly it tasted great, exactly what you’d want to expect from an Italian restaurant. The amazing part was the Blue Friday. Everyone was in their best Seahawks attire. Professional sportswear if you will. Our server was amazing. She was attentive, knowledgeable, and not too intrusive. That being said, there was a manager/host that left a sour taste in our mouths. This lady kept walking around the floor with her tablet, watching everyone eat and staring at our tables. If it was once it’d be one story. But she kept on checking every five minutes. It’s probably their procedure, but people started to notice. It felt like she was putting pressure on us to leave. No smile on her face, just her nose in the tablet then the stares. One seriously odd encounter is how much she watched our waitress. Every time our waitress would have an interaction with a table, the tablet lady would put down her tablet and watch the whole encounter. Overall weird experience with that. Otherwise, the food and the service was great. I just don’t like having “Big Brother” watching me and my waitress the whole time.

Alexander MakinanoAlexander Makinano

00

My wife and I went to Mama Stortini's for Valentine's Day. Realizing this is a very busy day for restaurants, this restaurant was very busy but it was still a very disappointing visit. First, a restaurant of thia level would typically provide some sort of bread, maybe even bread with some olive oil and balsamic vinegar, there was nothing. The small size dinner salad was really very good. It included some nice mixed greens, cucumber, and tomatoe. My wife had spaghetti and meatballs. It seems the spaghetti may not have been drained, so the sauce seemed to be watered down. This impacted the taste and also meant the dinner wasn't very hot. I had the Lasagne, and it also wasn't very warm. My wife liked the flavor, for me it wasn't very good. I really like the Spaghetti Factories Lasagne, so maybe what I like isn't great? Our table location was crap. Yes, we had a reservation, and we got lots of cold air from the front door. We both left with cold feet and just wanted to get to the car and get the heater cranked up. So for us, this will be the last visit to Mama Stortini's.

BoppaBoppa

00

I dont know why I waited so long to dine here. I've been driving by this restaurant weekly, since I moved to Puyallup a year ago. Wow, so delicious! My family and I dined for dinner on a Monday evening at 730p. It wasn't busy at all and the staff was friendly. My son has food allergies and they communicated to the kitchen, and reassured every time they delivered anything if it would be an issue with ingredients or cross contamination. I am so thankful for that. They give crayons and a color page, with an affordable kids menu of greats portions. We ordered the goat cheese bruschetta, small ceasar salad, papa's lasagna, salmon special, chicken tenders with fries and pineapple cake for dessert. Everything was fresh and seasoned wonderfully. We loved everything!! Will definitely be back to try many more dishes on the menu. Make sure to join their generous rewards program that has coupons and quickly earned points redeemable for cash off future visits. Thanks Lisa G for your attentiveness and great service.

Ashley McKeanAshley McKean

00

Decided to have mom/son time after track, not often this single mom of 3 gets that when i have a 15 yr old son and 7 yr old twin girls lol.. they seated us at the emergency door when there were plenty of open nice seating available. The food took forever to come out, was cold. My pasta was $17 for two small cannelloni the size of an Oscar myer weiner, my sons Cajon pasta $20 was over seasoned and the pasta was hard and chewy I told her he can't have the prawns if we could substitute she said sure no charge so he asked for Italian sausage his favorite... it came out with no Italian sausage. When I asked her she said it was an upcharged so she had them put extra andouille instead without informing us. So I ordered him pasta off the happy hour pastabilities which was 7.95 ( super small)he got speggetti (undercooked) marinara and Italian sausage which came to 12 bucks becauseof the Italian sausage. She was friendly in a cold, snubby way so $85 bucks later ... I'm home making a steak lol..

Sheena CowanSheena Cowan

00

Absolutely love it here! I come here often, a lot of the time for all day happy hour on Sunday or Monday. Great selection, everything I've tried is delicious and drinks are so good👍🏽

Ashley SantanaAshley Santana

00