Dream Catch — Restaurant in Saint Marys

Could have been better for my first time eating there. First off, I was given a specific time to pick up which was 30mins after I got off the phone. Upon arriving there, I had to wait another 15mins. They seemed disorganized and while waiting another customer was there. They were told a half an hour as well and after that passed, they were still waiting. Next, the below is the food that was ordered. Most if not all of the food had no flavor and was bland. The stuffed haddock was undercooked and liquidy and you couldn't really taste the crab at all. It probably was imitation crab canned crab. The Alfredo did not have any real alfredo or cheese taste to it. Maybe a little parmesan and pepper would make it taste better. The breadsticks were actually really good. My daughter tried the Alfredo and said it tasted like Olive Gardens and it wasn't that great! I would have thought the chicken would be cut and mixed in, instead of large, kinda round slices layed on top. The french fries were under cooked but did have a little flavor to them. They taste better then McDonald's fries though! The lobster mac and cheese tasted more like cheese then lobster. I would have though there would be chunks, but it looked more like slivers. I don't think it was even real lobster in the Mac and cheese, but the pretend Louis Kemp lobster delights you buy at Walmart. The cornbread was really soft and cake like, so I don't think thats cornbread. Why you say? Well, it's because any and all cornbread I use to eat was crumbly and semi stiff, to the point where you inhale the small pieces and it ends up choking you and makes you cough and this is not! Now let's talk about the blt lobster rolls that were a disappointment at $25 for two. First, neither of my blt had the b. Second, it had no flavor except the taste of a burned roll. If you had that cup of whatever they give you with the haddock and you put it on the lobster roll, Oh my goodness it's amazing! Take this sauce/concoction that would give it plenty of flavor and be delicious! Lastly, the small cup sauce/concoction that came with the haddock, that was nice. Like I said above, pair it with the lobster roll...

Delightful Seafood Haven: A Crab Lover's Dream

Nestled in the heart of St Mary's, Pennsylvania, this charming seafood restaurant is a true gem for any lover of ocean delicacies. From the moment you step inside, you're greeted with the inviting aroma of freshly boiled seafood and the warm hospitality of the owner.

Crab-tivating Delights: The star of the show here is undoubtedly the crab legs. Cooked to perfection, each bite bursts with sweet, succulent flavor, leaving you craving for more. Whether you prefer them steamed, grilled, or boiled, this place knows how to satisfy your crab cravings.

Seafood Boil Extravaganza: If you're in the mood for a feast, look no further than their seafood boil. Brimming with an array of treasures from the sea, including shrimp, clams, mussels, and more, every bite is a symphony of flavors dancing on your palate. Be prepared to roll up your sleeves and dive into a messy, yet utterly satisfying culinary adventure.

Heartwarming Hospitality: Beyond the delectable dishes, what truly sets this restaurant apart is the genuine warmth and friendliness of the owner. From recommending the freshest catches to ensuring your dining experience is nothing short of exceptional, their hospitality adds an extra layer of enjoyment to your meal.

Verdict: Whether you're a seafood aficionado or simply looking for a memorable dining experience, this seafood restaurant is a must-visit. With mouthwatering crab legs, indulgent seafood boils, and a welcoming owner, it's the perfect spot to satisfy your cravings and leave with a smile...

I came here just a day after they opened. The place is clean and very welcoming. Excellent color choice for the interior. Will remind you of a beach front with the turquoise/teal accents on white walls. The staff were very friendly and more then happy to answer questions from the customers. They have a fish market right up front that all seem to be fresh. Along side it is a grab and go bar for those who don't have time to sit and enjoy the bigger hot meals. It got a little busy towards the end of my stay. My wait time for the food was close to 20 minutes. I ordered the Ultimate Basket. Which included 3 Grilled Shrimp, Grilled Scallops and a Crab Cake with a choice of 2 sides ( Hushpuppies and Vegetables). The Shrimp and Scallops had the same seasoning used on them. They were delicious and done to perfection. No rubbery texture in sight. The cocktail sauce was homemade. More of a salsa then what you may be used but it packed flavor and a good amount of what you would call "heat". The Crabcake was honestly the best I ever had. Exceptional in every way. Good size and whole chunks of Crab were found in every bite. The stuffing used was amazing. The Dill/Thousand Island sauce mix thay paired with that was very good. The Hush puppies where deep fried to a very amazing crunch outside and soft fluffy inside. This was also paired with a sauce called jojos pepper sauce. It wasnt my cup of tea but nothing to throw off the meal from a 5 Star Experience!!! Highly recommended to anyone who enjoys and grand...