Bartoli's Oven — Restaurant in Sandycreek Township

Learned a valuable lesson about not judging a book by its cover. Got an Italian sub not expecting much from a little gas station place, I work in pest control so I have a habit of always looking back into the kitchen while I wait if I can, and I noticed that it was very clean, which isn’t common. Got the sandwich, which I get often from probably hundreds of places at this point, and it was top tier. Good bread, good ingredients, tomatoes were crisp, very impressed and will return again when I’m in the area. Don’t overlook this place because it’s a small...

Great staff! Very kind and fun to talk too! The pizza was very good! A hidden gem for sure! I enjoyed the pizza on the way home to Grove City. One bite everyone knows the rules..7.4 on the pizza. I could have that as my pizza place forever and be...

This is my favorite pizza, believe it or not, some deliciousness ❤️. Always a shocked look when I mention it, often hear "Isn't that a gas station". Reply "It sure is, but it's so much more!!" It's my usual pick for my...