Carlinis Pizza Shop — Restaurant in Shadyside

I have been ordering pizza here for over 7 years. Last night I ordered the usual a Tray pepperoni and cheese with extra pepperoni with light sauce. As we began to eat our dinner half way through I had a rubbery long pc of something get stuck in my throat causing me to choke. I got it pulled out and it looked as if it was either caulking off something or wrapping off of a meat, but it wasn’t clear to as what it was. My husband takes the unfinished pizza and the pc into Carlini to show them what had happened. The owners son Josh was very rude and sarcastic. He said it was the wrapping off the pepperoni and there was nothing he could do about that. While waiting to figure what Josh was going to do about the pizza he was complaining to his other employees about how he has to do everything by himself. End result they put our name down for another pizza and advised us we don’t order the pepperoni anymore… If their son can’t handle the pressure of a business maybe they need to revaluate their staff. Randy and Jocelyn are great people, but this was...

This is absolutely my favorite pizza place around here, has been since zontinis in Bellaire shut down. I love the square pizza, the subs, calzones, and pepperoni rolls are huge and delicious, & the prices are definitely decent. I do have one concern though. I chose delivery and when the driver got here (30 minutes later 😀) the kid looked like he was maybe 16 tried to short my fiancee $20.. even after spending $28 plus giving him a $7 tip... My fiancee watched him shuffle the money in his hand as he was counting it and gave him all the $5 and $1s but pulled the $20 back so my fiancee counted it and sure enough it was $20 short. The guy got almost in his car and my fiancee went and got the money back but the guy didn't even try to argue or even count his...

Very nice crust sauce good the thing that messed the pizza up cheese need to be stringy like mozerella should or baked better the prices are reasonable. Im a foodie read reviews i do have high expectations on when people say the best they do beat the others in area all but one. But overall need a...