Fresh Horses Saloon — Restaurant in Springdale Township

Sadly very disappointed on Saturday night. After having a great experience over the winter we brought guests back to try what we remembered was delicious and amazing "cowboy cut" prime rib dinners and were both horrified and embarrassed. The waitress was so very rude from the moment we were seated. She was absolutely terrible- didn't even say hello to us. Every one's prime rib was served cold and was just thrown on the table with the waitress announcing "I have no idea who's is who's so you can figure it out". We had all ordered mushrooms, onions, blue cheese crumbles- the prime ribs had none of it. I spoke up and asked to which the waitress just rolled her eyes and came back 10 minutes later with tiny paper plates with a few cold sliced mushrooms and blue cheese crumbles fresh out of the refrigerator. The au jus wasn't even warm enough to melt the blue cheese. Waitress as I've stated was embarrassingly rude but after being treated SO horribly I did tell her that these prime rib dinners were not acceptable and that had I never been there before I wouldn't know any better- but I HAD been there before and I KNEW full well that this was not how they were supposed to serve their prime rib. She asked if I wanted them thrown back on the grill. No. Thanks though. We won't be back. And I'm sad because the first time we were there we had SUCH a great meal and...

Edit 5/10/2020. We ordered the rueben and the brisket sandwich with tater tots and fries.

We of course ordered carry out due to the virus, we called ahead and when we got there they were prompt and quick to hand out the food.

The food - Ruben and brisket was super good. Tater tots were excellent as well. My main disappointment here was the fries. They were nice and crispy, but with not that much salt, but my main beef was that they didn’t provide ketchup, which made it a lot harder to eat those fries, granted, I didn’t request any because I assumed it would be included. Also they didn’t provide napkins which I thought was weird as well.

TL;DR- ask for ketchup for the fries, if they say they don’t provide that for carry out, get the tater tots, much easier to eat.

Old review - Great food, had the steak sandwich and my wife had the beef brisket. Both are $9.49. food was very tasty. I only wish for bigger portions because...

Too bad, this place has potential. I've been here a few times now and I can tell you that I hope you are patient because you'll be waiting for service. I'm talking like waiting 15 minutes for a refill because your server has completely forgotten that she mentioned it looked like you could use one. I'm talking waiting 45 minutes for a cheeseburger and 2 nachos. I'm taking being given someone else's check after my wife and kid couldn't wait for the check any longer so they left without me. It's almost like 2 people can't manage 50+ patrons and a bar rail on a Thursday evening.

They have a kid's menu but no kid friendly drinks, just a small soda. The food is pretty decent though. Could be better but I'm not complaining about it since compared to the service it was like fine dining.

The men's room was also gross, no toilet paper, and the door handle was broken. I'll never be returning...