Alfie's Pizzeria & Restaurant — Restaurant in Town of Brookhaven

Alfie's Pizza is an absolute gem that deserves all the praise! From the moment we stepped in, the owners made us feel incredibly welcome and treated us like royalty throughout our dining experience. Our journey began with a delectable selection of fried calamari, wings, and mozzarella sticks that were simply out of this world - each bite bursting with flavor and perfectly cooked.

For our main course, we savored the Penne allá vodka with grilled chicken and the classic chicken parmigiana. Both dishes were cooked to perfection, with flavors that danced on our taste buds and left us craving more. I must say, I am forever grateful to my friend Camille for introducing us to this culinary haven.

Not to mention the amazing drinks that perfectly complemented our meal and added an extra layer of enjoyment to our evening. The overall experience at Alfie's Pizza was nothing short of wonderful, and to top it all off, we were surprised with a Delicious Tartufo on the house - a sweet ending to a perfect meal.

We left Alfie's Pizza with full and content hearts, already planning our next visit with family and friends. The team at Alfie's truly goes above and beyond to create a warm and inviting atmosphere, and their dedication to providing exceptional food and service shines through in every aspect. Thank you, Alfie's Pizza, for a memorable dining experience - we are thrilled to have discovered this...

What a great find!! We wanted some pizza delivered but couldn’t agree on a place. We were both tired of our usual places so we decided to give Alfies a try. When our order said delivered but nothing had arrived I called up - I figured it was a computer glitch. The manager told us it was waiting for pick up and apologized profusely for the wait. I offered to come pick it up but she insisted on bringing it herself. 10 min later one of the chefs was at my door also apologizing again and again while he was handing over a hot pie. In a day an age where all we see are negative reviews and Karen’s - it’s refreshing to see real customer service!

The food … The pizza was great! We got half white which was very tasty - not bland like some places. This had flavor! The other half their classic plain - so good! The sauce is wonderful! We also loved the garlic knot crust. They even threw in something to apologize for the delay.

It’s hard nowadays to find a place that has great food and great customer service. This place has both! We’ll definitely be...

Wow, wow, wow!!! I came here a few times And ordered my usual, a large pie , meatball parm and some garlic knots. The food was delicious, pizza was soft with the right texture of crispyness on the crust, the meatball parm was so tasty in that signature tomato sauce and the garlic knots were so aift and garlicky, so good .

Listen, if you live in rocky point or neighborhood towns and have not tried this place , your missing out !!! They have a dine in area as well as togo counter to sit or carryout .

This is a new place and Iam a big time pizza enthusiast, most nee places let me down , this one blew my taste buds away, friendly staff, clean and organized etc.

Im just a paying customer , and trust me , try this place and be sure and ready to leave ur usual spot . This is the situation I’m in now , Its crazy.

Please message me if you think this review is...