Petey's Taps & Caps Grill — Restaurant in Town of Brookhaven

I stumbled on Petey’s Taps and Caps while trying to kill some time during my daughter’s soccer practice—and now it’s my go-to spot. First came in to catch a Knicks playoff game and ended up finding a great little bar. Every time I’m there, I meet someone new. The vibe is super friendly, and the staff is awesome—especially Stacy on Tuesday nights. She’s always welcoming and just cool to talk to.

The steak sandwich? Phenomenal. And the tap beer selection is seriously impressive. I’m hooked on the Voodoo Ranger. The place has a great atmosphere and a cool backstory behind the name. It’s still fairly new, but from what Stacy said, it’s doing really well—and I can see why. I'm in there every Tuesday and Thursday night now. If you’re anywhere near the area, I 100% recommend...

My friend and I came here for the first time. Really enjoyed it. The Happy Hour prices on drinks and appetizers are excellent. We had the fried mushrooms with horseradish sauce. For my meal I had the quesadillas with shrimp. My friend had the BLT and curly fries. For dessert we shared the rice pudding. Petey came by to introduce himself and tell us about his caps. He called his mom over so we could compliment the service and food. ...

It’s a tough building (Architecturally) & we have seen owners come & go: THIS IS A KEEPER!! - you Must come & check it out. It’s for real! That’s all I’ll say. We will be back - many times.Matt took great care of us Food quality is AMAZING:) Juicy meats, fresh food, ample portions, great quality & prices, Lovely people too. There’s no comparison; not a rip-off like...