Seaside Sally’s Shack — Restaurant in Town of Islip

We had a terrible experience eating lunch at Seaside Sally’s Shack. We ordered wings, fries, chicken tenders, and a hot dog, and honestly, not a single thing was good. The wings were completely inedible. They looked and tasted like they had been left in the freezer since last season. There was no meat, they were completely dried out, and they were so small they were the size of my pinky. Easily the worst wings I’ve ever had. Everything fried had the same weird sour taste, like the oil hasn’t been changed in forever or something was wrong with it. Even the fries and tenders had that same gross flavor, so we barely touched anything. Then they charged five dollars each for cheap knockoff ice cream. I’ve had better ice cream from a gas station for less money. I have no idea how this place has decent reviews because our experience was honestly awful. I won’t eat there again and I definitely wouldn’t recommend...

Worst Experience Ever!!! Walked in to girls behind counter talking to boys. Total ignored us then when they finally acknowledged us had a complete attitude with me. I'm Sorry I took you away from your conversation and God forbid you are pleasant when you approach me! I had to walk out before I lost it because when I asked a question the girl had a huge attitude!!! I guess that's what you get when you hire immature children!!! Terrible...

This place is a lot of fun! Great staff-great food with phenomenal wings (try the dry rub) and even better DRINKS!!!! Try the...