A B C Pizza & Restaurant — Restaurant in Town of New Windsor

I'm only giving one star because we had a nice waitress. I wish I could give it 0 stars.

I ordered the "stuffed chicken parm". When I ordered it, they asked if I wanted ham or broccoli. I thought thay was strange. What I got was a frozen chicken cordon bleu, covered in overly acidic sauce and a little cheese. I know for a fact that's what they were because my mother fed them to me growing up. Those chicken cordon bleu breasts cost $3.42 for two at Walmart. So they spent, $1.71, and charged me $20. Also what they actually charge you is not what is listed on the menu. I also got a side of spinach instead of pasta. I asked for it to be sautéed in garlic. The waitress told me no problem. What I got was a bag of frozen chopped spinach, with jarlic (jarred garlic) drenched in oil. It was utterly inedible.

I should have taken better pictures, but i was so annoyed i didnt. If i wasnt with my family, one of them who suggested the place, i would have sent back my meal.

10/10 do not recommend. Especially for dinner. I hear the...

Horrible service! They don't deliver so I went to pick up my order. Good thing I checked it before leaving because they messed it up. I decided to wait the 15 minutes to have them make the correct meal. They left the rest of my food sitting on the counter the entire time, they didn't try to do anything to keep it warm. When it finally came out the guy went to make the salad that came with it (because the 15 minutes I waited apparently wasn't long enough for him to make it). Then I asked for an extra blue cheese for my wings. He says ok but it's going to be 60 cents. So after having my order messed up, waiting for a new meal while the rest of my food got cold, not getting any sort of money off for the mistake (my bill was over $50) they couldn't even give me 60 cents worth of blue cheese. And the real kicker was that the food was horrible. I will never go here again, there are 4 other places nearby that deliver that I will use...

This used to be my place when we lived here. Loved the pizza. After coming back from being away for 2 years, I decided to go back to my favorite pizza spot with my family. Once we arrived, I guess our party was “too big” (13 people) and that they didn’t have room for us when only 5 people were eating inside the restaurant. All this being told with an attitude, and said “we need to call ahead of time, we can’t take you guys”. I didn’t think it would be an issue since we were gonna spend hundreds to support a local business. But after all that being said, we decided to just leave to not tolerate the waitress with an attitude. Sucks that this was my go to spot but the service wasn’t how I remembered. Guess I won’t be going here anymore. Food is great but...