Tony's Pizza Shop — Restaurant in Town of Newstead

Ok, so I need to give you some context for this review. I am from Pittsburgh, my wife is from Akron. We live in Pittsburgh. Being together 13 years i have had pizza and wings from all over the Buffalo NY area when we visit family. With that being said I can say Tonys medium wings are the best in western NY, yes better than Anchor Bar and Duffs. When we visit Akron I have to have these wings! NOW with that said, here is the reality, they are very expensive, and their pizza is maybe average at best. My wife likes the calzones, i just want the wings. So in the end I cant reccomend the pizza, however the medium wings, and i stress medium, are the best around, expensive, yes, but well worth it...

Placed order from their online menu . When I arrived to pick up my order it was more than fifteen dollars more than what the menu said. They said menu was outdated by five years . Can't see why they can't update it. Also no prices of food items posted anywhere in their shop . So they can probably charge you anything they want. Get your price over the phone before you go. As for the outdated menu I would call that false advertising. I'd give less than one star. Employee was very verbally abusive when I told them I didn't want their food items anymore at their overpriced food which was two salads and up to eight chicken strips for over...

If I could give this place 0 stars, I would. They wouldn't dress the fingers for my salad and said it would be 45 minutes for 2 salads. It's Thursday and they are SALADS. They are served in thin cardboard to go boxes that soak up the moisture from the lettuce etc... my box broke and my salad fell on the floor. Disappointed is an understatement. And CASH ONLY? It's 2024. Every single restaurant I know of takes card. Evading taxes or...? Either way, shame on Tony's Pizza. Won't be returning. Sad because I used to get their pizza as a kid a lot and even that has...