Two Sister’s Diner — Restaurant in Town of Theresa

You have to check this place out! This family-friendly diner is ideal for breakfast and lunch. We visited for lunch this time and loved the variety of seating options, including tables, booths, and food bar stools. Two Sisters offers daily specials and a tasty menu.

We tried the Bacon Cheeseburger Special, complete with toppings, crispy fries, and coleslaw. The burger was a juicy third-pound, cooked to order with a nice crispy edge and just the right amount of fat. While the bun was a bit large and did not taste toasted, it came with a side of mayo for customizing. We ordered ours medium well, but they accommodate different preferences.

Each bite of the fresh, crisp lettuce added to the experience. To prevent the bun from falling apart, I recommend cutting the burger in half. The bacon was satisfyingly crispy, and the fries had a subtle breaded flavor, making them a great complement to the beef gravy. The portions are generous, so come hungry!

The coleslaw was finely chopped with julienned carrots and just the right amount of dressing, leaving us wanting more after finishing our side. Our server, Sue, was friendly and attentive, ensuring everything was to our liking. The only downside was a pesky fly in the environment.

The pie slices looked tempting, and I couldn’t resist ordering a raspberry cookie to go, which was a perfect ending to the meal. We definitely plan to return for more—especially for pie!

#baconcheeseburger #cheeseburger #fries #coleslaw #frsshicedtea #gravy #twosistersdiner #ny #nyfoodie...

Not pleased with this establishment but unsure if it’s because we came in on Father’s Day or if they are usually like this.

We weren’t greeted when we came in, weren’t told whether or not to seat ourselves, everyone just looked at us and continued working. After seating we waited 10+ minutes for someone to acknowledge us and take our drink order. Then waited another 15+ minutes for a few glasses of water and coffees. Coffees dropped off, waitress said nothing & continued to speak to everyone around us. Another 20 minutes pass and they get our food order. I ask what’s in the breakfast burrito and she goes “whatever you want” ok? Easy enough, I ask for eggs, potatoes, bacon and cheese. Waitress asked if I’d like mushrooms and peppers as well and I said yes. 30 minutes go by and we are finally brought our food.

Tortilla was dripping and soggy. I open it up, no cheese, no bacon and no potatoes. I had maybe one egg in there and the rest filled completely up with mushrooms & peppers.

I rated atmosphere 5 stars because everyone around us seemed to be happy and received great food and fast service. Us? Not...

My boyfriend and I decided to grab breakfast here before heading out for a day of activities and were sadly disappointed. I assume this is a place that is more for locals rather than tourists. The food was flavorless, greasy, and low quality. There wasn’t any seasoning, outside of butter. The home fries weren’t fully cooked, the omelettes was just eggs with a slice of Kraft white American cheese and canned mushrooms, and the lemonade was lemon water. My boyfriend did his best to enjoy his steak, bit the meat was too chewy and fatty for him to get more than two bites. We tried to cover the taste of everything with salt and pepper, but it didn’t really help. The only positive part of the experience was our server. The young woman was very nice and doing her best. She kept her smile and helpful attitude despite having to serve a room full of yelling older patrons making inappropriate comments the...