Saylor's Main Street Pizzeria — Restaurant in Watervliet

Saylor’s Main St Pizza deserves its own spot on the Pizza Hall of Fame (yes, that should be a real thing).

I placed a large order—like, “feeding a small army” large—and they didn’t blink. No panic. No delay. Just perfectly cheesy, crispy-edged, saucy goodness, delivered with the confidence of a team that knows they’re elite.

Every pizza came out hot and fresh, like it had just done a runway walk out of the oven. The crust had that perfect crunch-meets-chew ratio, the toppings were generous, and not a single slice was left behind. Even the pineapple-on-pizza skeptics were converted. Miracles were witnessed.

I don’t know who’s running the kitchen back there, but I suspect it’s a team of culinary ninjas trained in mozzarella warfare. Respect.

Saylor’s: 10/10, would abandon all future diets...

We called to place an order, first time customers at THIS location. We were not offered or told about any specials(which they did have as we saw a few min later online and we called back to order one), we were not asked what size pizzas, we were not told the price, and when we ordered said special, which came with bread sticks they didn't offer us the cheese or marinara sauce, just told us it came with marinara. When we picked it up we found out that we could've had cheese sauce. Then as far as the pizzas, one was good, but the other one was SO dry we didn't even eat it, and it was my favorite... chicken 🐔...

Decent pizza that tastes good! Crust is the perfect thickness for a hand tossed style pizza. Sauce is on the sweeter side. Toppings for this pie were sausage, onion and fresh tomato, which was a very nice combo. The cheese is good and smooth, not grainy like other local pizzerias. They cut it in rectangles, which is not my favorite, but it was still good! I'll definitely order from Saylors again, and I'm looking forward to trying some of their other menu items as well as different pizza topping combos. I'm also very pleased with the...