HTML SitemapExplore

Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza — Restaurant in Wharton

Name
Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza
Description
Nearby attractions
Hurd Park
Dover, NJ 07801
Robert Street Park
164 Robert St, Wharton, NJ 07885
Nearby restaurants
4 Seasons
322 S Main St, Wharton, NJ 07885
Good morning breakfast and lunch
312 S Main St, Wharton, NJ 07885
Nearby hotels
Related posts
Keywords
Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza tourism.Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza hotels.Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza bed and breakfast. flights to Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza.Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza attractions.Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza restaurants.Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza travel.Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza travel guide.Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza travel blog.Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza pictures.Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza photos.Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza travel tips.Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza maps.Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza things to do.
Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza
United StatesNew JerseyWhartonTheodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza

Basic Info

Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza

336 S Main St, Wharton, NJ 07885
4.6(265)$$$$
Save
spot

Ratings & Description

Info

attractions: Hurd Park, Robert Street Park, restaurants: 4 Seasons, Good morning breakfast and lunch
logoLearn more insights from Wanderboat AI.
Phone
(973) 989-8363
Website
theodorasrestaurantpizza.com

Plan your stay

hotel
Pet-friendly Hotels in Wharton
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Affordable Hotels in Wharton
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Wharton
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Featured dishes

View full menu
Eggplant Rollatini Primavera
(Small tray, large tray)
Meatballs Or Sausage & Peppers
(Small tray, large tray)
Fried Calamari Or Calamari Marinara
(Small tray, large tray)
Buffalo Wings
(36 pcs.) (Small tray, large tray)
Chicken Fingers
(30 pcs.) (Small tray, large tray)

Reviews

Nearby attractions of Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza

Hurd Park

Robert Street Park

Hurd Park

Hurd Park

4.7

(178)

Open 24 hours
Click for details
Robert Street Park

Robert Street Park

4.6

(77)

Open 24 hours
Click for details

Things to do nearby

Full Moon Night Hike  & Bonfire✨
Full Moon Night Hike & Bonfire✨
Fri, Jan 2 • 6:00 PM
The New Weis Center for Education, Arts & Recreation, 150 Snake Den Road, Ringwood, United States
View details
Gay Socials Neat Connections
Gay Socials Neat Connections
Fri, Jan 2 • 7:00 PM
The Laundromat, 4 Dehart Street,Morristown, New Jersey, United States
View details
Joe Cirotti Trio and Rees Shad - In Person & Online at The Troubadour
Joe Cirotti Trio and Rees Shad - In Person & Online at The Troubadour
Fri, Jan 2 • 7:30 PM
21 Normandy Heights Rd., Morristown, NJ, United States
View details

Nearby restaurants of Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza

4 Seasons

Good morning breakfast and lunch

4 Seasons

4 Seasons

4.8

(292)

Click for details
Good morning breakfast and lunch

Good morning breakfast and lunch

4.7

(59)

Click for details
Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Wanderboat LogoWanderboat

Your everyday Al companion for getaway ideas

CompanyAbout Us
InformationAI Trip PlannerSitemap
SocialXInstagramTiktokLinkedin
LegalTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

Get the app

© 2025 Wanderboat. All rights reserved.

Posts

Ali MalikAli Malik
Please avoid at all costs. I have gone to them several times and their service has usually been excellent. However, I ordered a simple case of 6 fried Oreos today. I have had them several times in the past and they tasted just fine. Today, however, they tasted solely of the peanut oil they are fried in. You cannot chew and swallow them before the taste of the burnt oil comes through so sharply and makes you want to gag. It was horrendous. I cannot tell you how awful these were compared to the past times I have had them. I called the restaurant politely and spoke with an Italian man and explained the situation. He interrupted me several times, explained this cannot be the case since I am the first man to complain of these awful taste, said if you don’t like them you can go elsewhere, and told me to screw off and hung up the phone. I have given them my business for several years as a local in the area, but their rude, inconsiderate, mocking, and inhospitable customer service has turned me away from them forever. I do not write any of this lightly or in jest. If they do not know how to speak with customers politely and listen, I ensure you they do not care about the quality of the food they serve you. Look elsewhere for food in Wharton and beyond. I promise you will not miss anything by avoiding this restaurant ran by mean-spirited bullies. Lastly, do not take anything to heart they may say in their comment to this message. They will claim I’m being selfish. I ensure I have nothing to I gain here but to provide you some wisdom from choosing a better place to give your hard-earned money and time.
Diane GrohowskiDiane Grohowski
I ordered a Veal Dinner which comes with Pasta, Salad & Roll, for $23.99. I asked for Whole Wheat Pasta and they charged me $3.99 Extra. My Salad was Horrible. Very Small Portion, Soggy, Drenched with Italian dressing. I threw it out. Then a Roll, which they didn’t even warm up for me. George tacked on 4% for using a Debit Card. So all together I paid Over $7.00 Tax Included. Over $31.00 for One Persons Dinner. I Inquiry about this and George hands me a dollar, I said you owe me more than one dollar. Not willing to reimburse me. He says, Everybody is charging extra now a days. What do you want me to do ? I walked out upset saying NEVER AGAIN ! What I don’t get is that My Family where Good Customers of Theodoro’s. He just lost some Good Customers over a few dollars. I will let locals know how tight George has gotten.
Chiara ChandohaChiara Chandoha
Super amazing Italian/Greek food restaurant! Service was good, food was delicious! Was visiting someone in St Claire's hospital just across the street, was the closest place to grab a bite! We had a slice of pizza to go and a kids chicken fingers and ff. I had a veggie calzone there in the dining room, it was huge, came with red marinara sauce. My friend said the pizza was good and her daughter loved the chicken fingers! Stop by, it's good food!
See more posts
See more posts
hotel
Find your stay

Pet-friendly Hotels in Wharton

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Please avoid at all costs. I have gone to them several times and their service has usually been excellent. However, I ordered a simple case of 6 fried Oreos today. I have had them several times in the past and they tasted just fine. Today, however, they tasted solely of the peanut oil they are fried in. You cannot chew and swallow them before the taste of the burnt oil comes through so sharply and makes you want to gag. It was horrendous. I cannot tell you how awful these were compared to the past times I have had them. I called the restaurant politely and spoke with an Italian man and explained the situation. He interrupted me several times, explained this cannot be the case since I am the first man to complain of these awful taste, said if you don’t like them you can go elsewhere, and told me to screw off and hung up the phone. I have given them my business for several years as a local in the area, but their rude, inconsiderate, mocking, and inhospitable customer service has turned me away from them forever. I do not write any of this lightly or in jest. If they do not know how to speak with customers politely and listen, I ensure you they do not care about the quality of the food they serve you. Look elsewhere for food in Wharton and beyond. I promise you will not miss anything by avoiding this restaurant ran by mean-spirited bullies. Lastly, do not take anything to heart they may say in their comment to this message. They will claim I’m being selfish. I ensure I have nothing to I gain here but to provide you some wisdom from choosing a better place to give your hard-earned money and time.
Ali Malik

Ali Malik

hotel
Find your stay

Affordable Hotels in Wharton

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
I ordered a Veal Dinner which comes with Pasta, Salad & Roll, for $23.99. I asked for Whole Wheat Pasta and they charged me $3.99 Extra. My Salad was Horrible. Very Small Portion, Soggy, Drenched with Italian dressing. I threw it out. Then a Roll, which they didn’t even warm up for me. George tacked on 4% for using a Debit Card. So all together I paid Over $7.00 Tax Included. Over $31.00 for One Persons Dinner. I Inquiry about this and George hands me a dollar, I said you owe me more than one dollar. Not willing to reimburse me. He says, Everybody is charging extra now a days. What do you want me to do ? I walked out upset saying NEVER AGAIN ! What I don’t get is that My Family where Good Customers of Theodoro’s. He just lost some Good Customers over a few dollars. I will let locals know how tight George has gotten.
Diane Grohowski

Diane Grohowski

hotel
Find your stay

The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

hotel
Find your stay

Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Wharton

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Super amazing Italian/Greek food restaurant! Service was good, food was delicious! Was visiting someone in St Claire's hospital just across the street, was the closest place to grab a bite! We had a slice of pizza to go and a kids chicken fingers and ff. I had a veggie calzone there in the dining room, it was huge, came with red marinara sauce. My friend said the pizza was good and her daughter loved the chicken fingers! Stop by, it's good food!
Chiara Chandoha

Chiara Chandoha

See more posts
See more posts

Reviews of Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza

4.6
(265)
avatar
1.0
3y

Please avoid at all costs. I have gone to them several times and their service has usually been excellent. However, I ordered a simple case of 6 fried Oreos today. I have had them several times in the past and they tasted just fine. Today, however, they tasted solely of the peanut oil they are fried in. You cannot chew and swallow them before the taste of the burnt oil comes through so sharply and makes you want to gag. It was horrendous. I cannot tell you how awful these were compared to the past times I have had them. I called the restaurant politely and spoke with an Italian man and explained the situation. He interrupted me several times, explained this cannot be the case since I am the first man to complain of these awful taste, said if you don’t like them you can go elsewhere, and told me to screw off and hung up the phone. I have given them my business for several years as a local in the area, but their rude, inconsiderate, mocking, and inhospitable customer service has turned me away from them forever. I do not write any of this lightly or in jest. If they do not know how to speak with customers politely and listen, I ensure you they do not care about the quality of the food they serve you. Look elsewhere for food in Wharton and beyond. I promise you will not miss anything by avoiding this restaurant ran by mean-spirited bullies. Lastly, do not take anything to heart they may say in their comment to this message. They will claim I’m being selfish. I ensure I have nothing to I gain here but to provide you some wisdom from choosing a better place to give your hard-earned...

   Read more
avatar
1.0
1y

I am very upset by my recent experience with Theodora's. I have been going here for more than 10 years as their pizza is one of the best across town. I recently took a trip a week ago and was astounded that there was no working A/C in their place. It also took 15 minutes to put in my order and another 15 for my order to be ready (I ordered a slice of pizza). Whoever took my order was the probably one of the rudest employees I have ever encountered. I felt no friendly atmosphere as I am used to here, and to make matters worse, he sternly told me that no outside drinks were allowed (I brought a bottle of water). This made me extremely mad because he was being inconsiderate with how hot the restaurant was. He watched me down throughout the rest of my dining experience to make sure I did not grab a sip of my water. And finally, when it came time to pay, it took much more longer than it needed to. This guy was ringing me up and took a call and began arguing with the person on the phone. I don't know what his issue was but it really bothered me so much with how he treats customers that I had to...

   Read more
avatar
1.0
5y

Unfortunately I am rating on service and belligerent treatment by the owner. We ( two females) were seated before a party of 6 men and a party of 2 arrived. Waitress took our order immediately after the table of 6. Table of 2 arrived after that. Table of 6 and 2 meals were served about 10 minutes after orders were taken. We waited 30 minutes and finally questioned waitress about status of our order pointing out that we had arrived before both tables and table of 2 had completed their meals and left already! Owner then came out and RUDELY asked what the problem was. I explained the situation and he ARROGANTLY said it takes a while to grill vegetables ( I had ordered a veggie wrap)! In the meantime another gentleman customer had arrived.; his order was taken and his food arrived two minutes after ours did. He arrived 60 minutes after us; order was taken and he finished his meal the same time we did! The owner definitely needs lessons in customer service. I must say the food was very good. Too bad the chef’s talents are wasted in this...

   Read more
Page 1 of 7
Previous
Next