Pie, Oh My! — Restaurant in Youngstown

I live out of state, and wanted a very specific kind of butterscotch pie made for my parents who live in the area. I stumbled upon this business, and I am so glad I did! Jenny took the time to hear exactly what I wanted, and even offered to make my great grandma’s recipe! It was homemade, delivered to their door, and perfect!! Her price was so affordable, too. Jenny was a pleasure to work with from start to finish. I can’t imagine that you’d get this kind of customer experience at a chain restaurant....

During a cross country road trip the hankering for pie struck. A quick search along our route yielded Pie, Oh My and man am I happy it did. The pie we bought was one of the best pies I have ever had (Cranberry Crumble) and the scones we got as well were amazing! Jen was extremely friendly, charming, and just all around amazing. If I am ever in the area again I will definitely go out of my way to acquire more...

These are the BEST pies EVER. Jenny is so accommodating and easy to work with. I purchased 36 minis and 1 large. It is about 1hr and 20 min from my home each way, but more than worth the trip. The ABSOLUTE best ever!!! Will never buy from anyone but Jenny!!! Wonderful crust and truly good filling. I will always be ordering from Pie, Oh My!! Thank you Jenny. See you around...