O'Shea's Candies — Attraction in Geistown

We have been here quite a few times but am rethinking whether they need my business. We got there at about 7:35PM

I asked for a blackberry milkshake for my husband but the server said they had run out of milk. My husband told me he did not want anything, because he usually only gets milkshakes. Then I asked for the peanut butter lovers sundae but the server said she could not give me that either , since they were getting ready to close! I am assuming they stay open til 8 pm, so now I wonder if they really ran out of milk for the shake or just told me that because they needed to clean the machine before closing at 8.

Their website says they are open only til 7 pm yet they were still serving someone ahead of me and it was past 7:30. I think that they get paid only til 8 and I get that but the server could have just told me upfront that they were closing instead of hoping that I was probably just going to get a scoop...

Coconut pigs, peanut butter cups, the different chocolate clusters,,, so many favorites! Regarding the chocolate specifically O’Shea’s (milk, dark) is excellent quality always consistent and smooth. They do make their own chocolate at facility close to the Johnstown stores. The stores are well stocked and they’ll even wrap and ship for you. Also, as others mentioned below, the team at the stores greet you with a smile, in our many years as a customer we’ve never had a bad experience. Good deals as well with frequent purchase card. Thanks...

Really great ice cream. Lots of tasty (and crazy!!) Flavor combos to choose from. They'll let you sample the flavors before you buy, which is nice. Amanda helped us out, and she was attentive and speedy. They always give ample ice cream at reasonable prices (three sizable scoops in a specialty waffle cone cost about $3.65.) I could have easily split it with my Mom and have had some left over. They also have Penn State Creamery ice cream. And they always top your ice cream with a little...