Great Island Inn — Hotel in New Castle

I stayed in one of the main studios downstairs with my husband and my parents (four adults total) for my father's 70th birthday from a Wednesday night to a Saturday morning. I paid on average about 580 per night before tax. I would personally describe my overall stay as just OK, and will share details below:

Pro: Clean Spacious Cute nautical decor Well stocked refrigerator and snacks Has most of the amenities that you'd expect at a hotel like this Good location Working internet

Con Since I visited with my elderly parents, I ended up sleeping on the pull out sofa, which was not very comfortable. It seems like the sofa bed was a bit broken and doesn't lay flat anymore, so my legs were more elevated than my head. The ceiling was thin and very squeaky, and could often hear when the people above us walk, which wasn't ideal for me who's sensitive to sound. This could be circumstantial, but I was already waking up at 8am every morning to work, but the people who stayed above us woke up even earlier than me, which made the stay a bit uncomfortable. It could help to put a thicker rug upstairs. We got to the hotel pretty late on Wednesday as we had to drive up, and saw that we were only give three towels when we specified there were four of us staying there. The towels are also very worn and needs changing. All of the outlet on one wall of the room wasn't working properly when we arrived, and so we had to flip the circuit breaker. It turns out that the toaster would trip the circuit breaker, and we'd have to flip the circuit breaker again. It seems like the toaster was using too much power, and the owner didn't properly test if all of the amenities would work properly with the room.

I think all of the cons above are not deal breakers, but for a room where you pay close to $600/night I expected better quality from the items/products used...

This was our second time staying at the great island inn! Our stay was absolutely perfect! If you’re looking for a place that feels like home but offers the charm of a boutique stay, this is it. The apartment was beautifully designed, clean, and full of thoughtful touches, from the fully equipped kitchen to the in room washer & dryer, which was a lifesaver after our daily beach walks (rain or shine!). The location couldn’t be better! It’s tucked away in a quiet, historic neighborhood, yet it’s just minutes from downtown Portsmouth and Kittery, either a quick drive or a gorgeous 20-30 minute walk past historic homes, the waterfront, and over the bridges. The best part? The beach is only two blocks away with stunning lighthouse views! The bed was incredibly comfortable, and the space had so much character and attention to detail. Plus, having Islander cafe right downstairs was such a treat, amazing coffee and delicious breakfast without having to go far. If you’re looking for a peaceful, comfortable, and well-located place to stay, I can’t recommend Great Island Inn enough! We’ll definitely be back....

This is one of the nicest and most well appointed places to stay if you are coming to Portsmouth or New England for a visit. Doug and or his designers did a fantastic job. It is so relaxing and so nice to be in a comfortable room when away from home. As a side note, if you have ever written a review of a hotel and wished your bedroom was as comfortable it means you need a new mattress and let me say that you should always miss your bed more than you miss a bed from a trip. With that said the linens and mattress are very nice. Since I was referred to the Great Island Inn by a local business owner, I was not aware that it functions like an Airbnb. Doug is very responsive and if there is anything missing I am certain he would make every attempt to make sure your stay is one that will also have you writing a positive review. Skip Boston and head up to Portsmouth, Kittery, Portland, and Burlington. Do not, I repeat, do not forget to stop at Lil's in Kittery. You...