S & J Sports Cards and Collectibles — Local services in Muskogee

I had a bunch of sports cards that I didn't need because I prefer Magic the Gathering, Pokémon or Yu-Gi-Oh cards & I had heard about this card shop S & J SPORTS in Muskogee, OK so I took them in to trade & was I amazed at the sweet deal the owner John gave me for my sports cards. Not only did he give me cash for my cards but with the in-store credit I cashed in on all these packs of fresh new cards which the possibilities of scoring a few rare cards is awesome. I haven't opened them yet but no matter what's inside the packs, the deal John the store owner gave me was refreshing & no other card shops compare when it comes to Collectables. I highly recommend, S & J Sports Cards on 740 N. York St in Muskogee, Oklahoma because not only does this store have an extensive amount of sports cards, they also offer many other Collectibles such has Pokémon & Yu-Gi-Oh & Collectable figures, Hot Wheels, Football Jerseys, Plush characters & much, much more. There's only one thing that would have been nice to see, with all the other Collectibles, would have been some Magic the Gathering cards or merchandise but that's just my preference but it doesn't take anything away from this store being 100% well worth the drive because the owner is a very friendly, hard working Christian man with an amazing store. Thank you John. Sincerely...

Visited this shop and it's very disorganized. There are a lot of cards, but they are not that desirable. Most cards don't have prices listed anywhere and the owner tells you to just pick out what you want and "I will make you a deal". The boxes and trays of cards are not sorted by sport and are very disorganized, not in good shape and some cards are in sleeves and some are not. It's just randomly crammed tightly in boxes all over the place and it makes it hard to just look for what you might want and not get cards that have been damaged or manhandled by everyone searching through the boxes. Even new and old stuff is just crammed together and hard to go through. I picked out some stuff - but when I went to ask how much he wanted, I feel like I overpaid compared to what I get anywhere else in Oklahoma. Just organizing the cards by sport would be a great help and not take that much time, but it's not done here. I will not be visiting again as there wasn't that much good selection and the prices didn't seem great to me - but you have to get all that you want before he will tell you what he wants for anything you may pick out or want. The pictures on the google listing are also out of date and not representative of what the shop really...

I've been in the shop about 3 or 4 times. I brought cards each time. I'm a old school collector and thought he maybe a good place to trade, buy,etc... I gave him a couple of pages of cards he selected to trade. He made a deal to trade the pages for 200$. I shook his hand and turned around asked for the wax pack boxes he had for sale. They were 40$( marked). He looks at me says " oh,my wife says that I can't trade my boxes without marking them up." He states they are 50$. That's a 10$ mark up from the deal you just made and shook my hand on. The Graded cards available are not reputable grading companies. Do research because he's banking on you not knowing. If you can't keep your word over a small inconsequential deal, you can't be trusted to do anything just by word. I went back one time after and there was actually a guy talking smack to him about his integrity. I left. Always feel out any dealers. Unfortunately most do business like this guy. As an educated collector and a guy that's been around the block in the sports car trading world. This guy is not honest...he's actually just trying to get over on anybody because he has a shop. He's banking on you not knowing what you have. Fortunately for me I know what I have. Go...