Yoder's Amish Village Gift Shop — Local services in Sarasota

One of the things that stood out to me the most about Yoder’s Amish Village Gift Shop was how genuinely authentic everything felt. This isn’t just a place filled with “Amish-style” souvenirs—these are real, handcrafted items made by the Amish, many of which are sourced directly from communities in Pennsylvania and Ohio. From homemade jams, apple butters, and fresh-baked breads to hand-sewn quilts, wooden toys, soaps, and old-fashioned kitchen tools, everything carries that unmistakable touch of quality and care. You can tell the difference immediately—these are pieces made to last, not mass-produced. It was like taking a step back in time, surrounded by tradition and craftsmanship. If you appreciate real handmade goods, this shop is...

After eating at the restaurant, we browsed thru this gift shop across the parking lot, a very short walk. It was SO cute! The bathroom was also spotless. The clerk was informative and very friendly. Prices were as expected, and they had local art for sale. There were some lighted lanterns behind the counter which I loved but the clerk told me that had some returns and problems, so they decided not to sell them anymore, I thought that was very thoughtful of them! Take the time to walk around and...

This Amish gift shop, Amish Restaurant, and Amish Produce shop are all outstanding! Located in Sarasota, it's a short drive off of I-75. The food is always delicious. The service is always outstanding. Everything is AWESOME! Especially looking deep into my sexy Husband's eyes over a great meal. ❤️ 😍...