Grove Market — Local services in Town of Brookhaven

The prices are sky-high, but the bigger issue is the way seasonal help treats regular visitors to the island. And the owner allows it. I waited a long time by the deli counter until the employees took my order for a breakfast sandwich. The policy is that they give customers a receipt, the customer pays, receives a stamp, then presents that receipt to claim the order. The employee said she had the order for which I paid,, but when I presented the receipt, she ignored me, snickered, and handed my sandwich to a random person in the store. When I told the other employee about this, he told her to make another one, but this one was completely wrong. I asked for a refund, which they were reluctant to give. I can leave my money anywhere, but it won't be where I ...

My experience at this store was extremely disappointing due to the manager's condescending behavior. After I accidentally dropped an item, he scolded me, saying, "That’s why we have shopping carts." This was completely unwarranted. Given that they're the only store in town, it seems the manager feels entitled to treat customers poorly. On top of that, the store is overpriced and filthy. Avoid this store. I recommend bringing your food from the mainland or shopping at the Pines Pantry for respectful service.

BTW, I paid for the item which is the last time that establishment gets...

A great little store with an incredibly diverse inventory, for serving such a small community. They feature a good choice of vegan and organic food, and special little niche items like French lemonade and ginger ale if you’re setting up a bar for a party. They also have fresh coffee, brownies etc. Yes..they’re expensive! But it’s not easy getting everything they have out there, and it’s a great asset to the Cherry Grove community to have such a high quality store. Open seasonally, closed in the Fall after...