Cherry Grove Pizza — Restaurant in Town of Brookhaven

I loved this place until last night. I come here every summer. Last night there was hair in my lasagne. It was dark outside already so i couldn’t see. I was disgusted when i was chewing on hair. I used the flashlight on my phone to find a handful of dark long hairs in my lasagne. I was halfway through the lasagne, its not as though i finished it and then reported hair in my food. We told the waitress and all she offered was to discount our 2 soft drinks. My husband went to tell the guy inside and all he offered was an additional ten bucks off plus the deduction of the two soft drinks. I will never return here again or recommend it to friends as i always did. My husband did not want to cause a scene so he just paid and we left. Im Also going to spread the word across cherry grove. Nobody deserves to eat hair and then be expected to pay for it. So disappointing that a replacement meal wasn’t even offered, although i had lost my appetite at that...

If your at Cherry Grove ocean walk in Fire Island, Cherry Grove Pizza is the place to go. I greeted by the really nice waitress, who had a smile the whole time. She also made sure I got everything I needed and checked up on me to make sure a comfortable amount of times. I asked what she recommended, so I decided to go with the chicken hero. It was delicious, hot sub, 12’ and fulfilling. The cheese was on point and the bread was not hard on the ends and the chicken was perfect as expected. Great cooks. The other waitress was very nice, as I got up from my table she asked if everything was okay and if needed anything. I did not only enjoy my food but the service inside and out was 5star. I love and will...

Have been here a number of times with friends. On the one occasion I go by myself I sat at a table waiting for ANY waiter to pay enough attention to me to provide me with a menu. What is ridiculous is to see how as other people came to sit they provided menus in moments. I sat for 20 minutes patiently waiting and what is even more disappointing and upsetting is that as I stood up from the table I sat at and another party of 4 came to sit at the VERY table I waited to be acknowledged and served...a waiter had menus in hand as they followed them.

Working in the hospitality industry myself tend to be quite a great tipper since I know the challenges often associated with the job. INCREDIBLY DISAPPOINTING...