New York's Butcher Brothers — Local services in Town of Hartwick

We used to buy a lot of meat from the Amish butcher so I wasn’t expecting to be blown away by good meat because I was already used to it. But I just got a 1/2 cow from here, and everything I had was literally the best I’ve ever had! And everybody I fed said the same. amaaaazing rib eye! Wow! I totally cooked it improperly and botched the whole thing and ate without being hungry, and it was the MOST delicious piece of meat I’ve had in my...

What a hidden gem of a place. You just can’t find this high quality meat anywhere near here. Had a beef tenderloin roast for Christmas and everyone raved about it, the rib eyes are excellent and everything else, including cheese curds and other delicious bites they sell. All NYS raised and the prices are excellent for such quality and service! These guys know what...

Wow, Got 20# of ribs for fathers day. They melted in your mouth. They were packaged well, 9 ribs in a package which made it nice because 10 people cancelled so I just froze a pack! Thank you! They were sooooooo good! I thought the price was high untill I realized they were boneless! Great...