Forget The Grocery Store: Here Are Amazing Bakeries Serving Chicago’s Best Holiday Pies

Everyone knows the best part of Thanksgiving is the dessert, so instead of making one yourself, consider purchasing a pie from these recommended bakeries! Where to order thanksgiving pies in Chicago ------------------------------------------- Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits has a delicious selection of pies— roasted pumpkin, classic apple, chocolate pecan, cast-iron apple crisp, and Key lime. Along with the pies, you can purchase mini biscuits, savory pot pies, and pie-crust baked brie to complete your Thanksgiving dinner. Address: 2051 N California Ave, Chicago, IL 60647 Online orders can be picked up on November 25-26 . Café Yaya If you’re not feeling apple or pumpkin pie, then Café Yaya is the perfect deviation. The Middle-Eastern bakery will be offering Turkish Coffee Chocolate Cream Pie, along with a selection of pastries and rolls , including signature challah rolls and whole spiced pumpkin loaf. Address: 2431 N Lincoln Ave, Chicago, IL 60614 Order online here First Slice Café You can’t go wrong getting a slice of pie at First Slice Café —the name is in the title. They offer a variety of flavors, including the classic apple, pecan, pumpkin, and more eccentric options like sweet potato praline and balsamic raspberry pear. Address: Various locations The Goddess and Grocer The Goddess and Grocer is a Chicago favorite and offers all the classic holiday pies : pecan, salted caramel, pumpkin, and pumpkin cheesecake, available by the slice or as a whole pie. Address: Various locations A limited amount of Thanksgiving food will be available at all their stores beginning November 25th. Mindy’s Bakery There is always a line for pastry chef Mindy Segal at Mindy’s Bakery every single weekend, which is a testament to the delicious, sweet treats. This year, Mindy is featuring a pumpkin pie with butterscotch custard, topped with pepitas and toffee bits, and an apple-honey cake with caramelized apples and brown butter streusel. Address: 1623 N Milwaukee Ave, Chicago, IL 60647 Order online for pickup November 25-26. Milk Bar While everyone knows Milk Bar for the birthday cake truffles and compost cookies, they are going all out for Thanksgiving with tasty pies, including the Pumpkin Milk Bar Pie and Pumpkin C offee Cake—our mouths are already salivating. Address: 208 N Green St, Chicago, IL 60607 Source: https://secretchicago.com/where-to-get-thanksgiving-pie-in-chicago-2025/