Our Backyard BBQ — Restaurant in Amherst

Preface: In early October 2024, I visited this location around 2 pm, only to be told the smoker was 'broken' and no food could be served. I especially made sure to visit this location in the future, as smokehouse type bbq restaurants are quite scant in the maritimes. Today, I had the opportunity to finally try it.

I parked my vehicle in the closest available parking near the front door. The restaurant is located in a strip mall type setting, and parking is ample.

Upon exiting my vehicle, I find an intact, functioning cell phone. I entered the restaurant and presented the phone to the cashier, telling him I had found it outside. He looks at me and says,'What am I supposed to do with that?' As I presented it to him.

After an awkward exchange, I placed my order. A steak cut brisket, mashed potatoes, and a piece of cornbread, which amounted to 23$.

After a few minutes, my order appeared on a diner tray. The presentation was beyond deceiving and underwhelming. The potatoes were without starch structure and very watery, with a slight bit of garlic flavor. The cornbread was drier than a desert day, and it felt like sandpaper rubbing against the surfaces of my mouth.

The worst, though, was the brisket itself. It was very fatty, and covered with a very acidic bbq sauce, which completely ruined it for me.

As far as the restaurant itself goes, the dinning room consists of picnic tables and a few high chairs by the window. The restaurant is clean, well lit, and the menu is drawn in chalk, lending to it a rustic element. The bathrooms were clean and tidy.

Customer service was cold and indifferent, as described in my initial encounter.

Overall, I personally wouldn't try the menu item I chose. I would perhaps try their other offerings, but as it currently stands, I'm not sure I would go out of my way to visit again. Honestly, with it being the only thing I've consumed today, it's left me quite queasy. I can't directly attribute this to the restaurant or the...

Our Backyard BBQ in Amherst is a hidden gem for BBQ lovers, offering mouthwatering dishes that are sure to impress. The food was truly delicious, with the Ultimate Platter standing out as an absolute favorite. Packed with a variety of smoked meats and sides, it’s undoubtedly one of the best platters I’ve ever had—perfect for sharing or indulging all on your own.

The bread is another highlight—it’s fresh, warm, and quite literally to die for. It pairs beautifully with their BBQ offerings and is the kind of detail that keeps you coming back for more.

However, the service could use a bit of improvement. When we arrived, there was no one available at the counter, and we had to wait for some time. It seemed like it might be a one-person operation, which could explain the delay. While this didn’t overshadow the amazing food, a smoother greeting process would enhance the overall experience.

The ambiance is simple and relaxed, allowing the focus to remain on the food. Despite the small hiccup with service, I would highly recommend Our Backyard BBQ for anyone looking to enjoy some outstanding BBQ...

Hole on the wall type beat.

Walked in and was embraced by a comforting smoky smell of a good ol’ camp fire. Red rustic picnic benches and a full display of wood really tie the whole atmosphere together! The service was great, very friendly and polite, took our garbage/ dirty trays for us.

The food is the star of the show! I ordered a 1/2 rack of ribs and my spouse the smoked brisket sandwich with sides of baked beans, Mac and cheese, and apple coleslaw between the two of us. The meat was juicy tender and falling off the bone. The sauce perfectly compliments the smoky favours of the ribs having a beautiful tangy buffalo flavour without the heat! The Mac was the perfect amount of cheesy with a sprinkling of crushed cheese puffs on top really completes the homey feeling of this place. Not to mention the amount of food you get for the price!! Unbeatable!

If ever just passing through or looking for a good bite to eat I couldn’t be more excited to recommend this place!! So sad we’re traveling back to Ontario and have to wait what will seem like a lifetime before we can enjoy this Devine...