Ancaster Pizza — Restaurant in Hamilton

We had a delivery this evening. Two medium thin crust with 1Lb of wings and fries. I asked the person on the phone for the price so I could have the money ready for the driver. $43:88 I was told would be the cost. When the driver arrived it had risen to $50:88. I asked why when I was told $43:88…..Well you had extra toppings, but the phone person knew that before they told me the cost ??? The fries were cold as were the wings ( delivered in the same box ), My all meat pizza is so salty as to be inedible. Extremely disappointed this time. Never used to be like this. Time for a change I think. Ancaster pizza replied and apologized tremendously, they were having staffing issues which is now resolved. They have completely replaced our order. I thank them for standing up and resolving our issues. The sign of an...

I’ve been ordering from Ancaster Pizza for nearly a decade now, and it never disappoints. The quality, taste, and consistency of their food keep me coming back. Their pizzas are always loaded with fresh ingredients, perfectly cooked, and full of flavor. The dough is just the right mix of crispy and chewy, and their sauce has a great balance of sweetness and tang.

Beyond the pizza, their menu offers a great selection of other delicious items, and everything I’ve tried has been fantastic. The service is always friendly and reliable, whether I’m picking up or getting delivery. If you’re looking for a great local pizza spot, Ancaster Pizza is definitely...

We had a group order for 6 pizzas and some wings that we placed online, over an hour had passed and we never received our food, so we called and the person there told us that they never received our order - despite us receiving confirmation that the order was placed. They the told us it would be 45 more minutes. 15 minutes later, he called us back and then said the guy cooking them “wanted to go home” and they “couldn’t complete our order”.

They said to “call back tomorrow”. Not sure how that would help our situation of trying to feed a group of 12, but at least Jack Astors was open and friendly!

Completely altered our plans for the...