Main Street Italian Eatery — Restaurant in Milton

I’ve actually been here before and didn’t review it. I had gotten the chicken sandwich with onions and mushrooms. It was really good. I usually go to California sandwiches for a similar sandwich but now that I’m living in Milton, this is my go to sandwich shop now. The gentleman working that day was very nice, very friendly.

I just want to point out that I took these pictures after everyone had already started digging in. It was 5 large chicken cutlets.

Anyways, so today someone in our household had the idea of chicken cutlets for dinner. Usually it’s something we get from Longo’s which is down the street. Today I decided let’s try something different. I got there after the lunch rush as I had to head to a meeting in Oakville. I wanted to grab their gnocchi alla vodka but they had run out from the lunch rush. No problem, the lady helping me suggests that I get the cheese tortellini in a rose sauce to go with the chicken cutlets. Everyone at the home front was pleased with the food. Glad I got it right on time for dinner at 6pm. The cheese tortellini was superb. Tasted like how Nonna used to make. Chicken cutlet was perfectly cooked too and they were very large pieces. The food was very hot, I could hardly hold the trays when I picked it up. When I ordered, I wasn’t expecting so much pasta. Luckily a few friends came over and they had some food too and enjoyed it.

Anyways, while I was in the store making the dinner order which I would pick up later at 6pm, I decided to try the sausage sandwich - I asked to add a little bit of the tomato sauce from the chicken. Obviously with mushrooms and onions. It was good but I wouldn’t say it’s the best I’ve had. I really like spicy sausage and this sausage was more fennel taste, quite mild. I actually really wanted to try their meatballs but I guess they had run out of that because of the lunch rush.

The lady helping me was extremely helpful and very patient with me because I asked many questions. The best part was that the food was ready on time when I came to pick it up and I only waited about 5-10 mins.

Please check their Facebook page - the menu for the day is posted there. Also keep in mind, this plaza gets busy and their quantities run out.

All in all I would give it like a 4.2/5 - understanding that they get busy and run out of quantity. Price was reasonable. Customer service was on point. Seating area is small but good for 12 or so people. One bad thing is that the parking lot is tiny, especially if you’re driving a...

Great little ma and pa shop if you want to stop in for a lunch, but I would highly recommend not making the mistake of asking them to cater an event. Anyone who's lived in Milton long enough knows the reputation, food quality and service they put out. Typically, they are very warm, welcoming and friendly people. This is why I was excited to have them cater my wedding- This is also why I was shocked and appalled at what they brought to my wedding. The food was all cold- 5/5 trays. They were only 3 mins down the road from the event. I was worried about it being cold to begin with, and they had promised it was going to be warm because they were so close. They only provided 3 warming trays, and candles to heat only one tray. We were upset so didnt want to pay them in full - my dinner was postponed by 45 mins because of all of the food being that cold and us having to reheat all of it. The mother(I believe Teresa is her name) held herself in a somewhat professional manner to deal with the conflict- but the daughter I was disgusted with. They told me(on my wedding night infront of all my guests) with no receipt given on a cash only business they were going to call the police on me because I didn't pay on the agreed upon amount and hold my end of the deal, when I mentioned they did not do this either and I dont think I should have to pay the full amount the daughter started to yell at me(again infront of all my guests) and said word for word "I'm going to call the police on you and ruin your wedding night, what do you think about that" completely disgusting behavior. We ended up paying them to get them out of the building because I could not believe the way the conducted themselves infront of 80 people with such a good reputation in the community. They caused a huge scene... I was so embarassed. Upon speaking to a few people I was also informed the daughter screamed at a large table of my guests before even speaking to me about the situation. Who acts like that as a business owner? That could have and should have been dealt with way differently. There is a certain way you need to handle yourself in situations like that, and they are extremely unprofessional and have no idea on how to deal with conflicts. People skills need to be vastly improved. Sad to say, but after being a customer for almost 10 years I will never give them my business again after that...

Came here earlier today for the first time since I’ve moved to Milton 3 years ago. My wife and I have always driven past and said that we needed to try their famous chicken/veal parm sandwhichs. So today for my wife’s birthday I decided to stop in. First impressions were fine, I didn’t realize it was cash only, unfortunately the ATM was not in service but the owners were kind enough to give me the sandwhichs and tell me to come back anytime. Of course I drove right down the street to the Scotia bank and got them the cash. They were kind enough to say that I didn’t have to come back so fast, but of course I couldn’t wait as they trusted me enough to give me the food without paying.

Everything looked delicious, all of the families hands were helping. The service to myself as well as others in line were kind and informative. I find it sweet that if you’re eating in, they give you actual plates and cutlery as if you’re eating in their home. It was a sweet touch.

Everyone was very nice and I can’t wait to come back and try more of their dishes. The lasagna, veal and steak looked very good!!

Only comment is that I wish they had a posted menu with prices, I don’t mean to be a cheap person and keep asking for prices of different things, but of course when you go out to buy lunch, you have a...