The Courthouse Cafe — Restaurant in South Island

Based on the good reviews we decided to stop at the Courthouse Cafe for lunch, however we were extremely disappointed, and left feeling hungry and rather ripped off. I ordered the Mussel Chowder $23 and Gnocchi $20, along with 2 winter juices at $9 each. The Mussel Chowder arrived as a fairly good sized portion, with a slice of sourdough bread on the side. However, the Gnocchi turned out to be approx 9 very small pieces of potato sitting in a slightly burnt buttery oily sauce, served in a cereal bowl (albeit an upmarket one). The microgreens sitting on top of the Gnocchi turned out to be a larger than the actual portion of Gnocchi! The description on the menu was light potato dumplings, which is nothing like the Luke warm lumpy potato I was served. When comparing value for money to the price I paid for the Mussel Chowder there was no comparison. I know food prices have gone up, but surely butter isn't that expensive that it justifies $20 for such a small serving, sitting in a little buttery oily sauce?? Would I recommend going back? No, which is a shame as the cafe is in a lovely...

The Courthouse Cafe is an old historic establishment, the original court house in Collingwood, which has been restored keeping many of its original features and decoration. It serves delicious, fresh, local food and deserts, the most popular of which is their sumptuous chocolate torte. Unmissable for chocoholics! The building has several rooms featuring old photographs, utensils and books. Lovely atmosphere and beautiful, sunny outdoor seating. A local jewel and not to be missed if you are around Golden Bay. Great service too, and a friendly dog to pat on the...

I walked in the door on a Sunday morning after lockdown and the place was packed and the conversation loud. Food & service were excellent and the vibe was cheerful. I sat and enjoyed my brunch in this lovely cafe in a delightful seaside village and a thought struck me. I need to find a wonderful woman and take her there for dinner. Yes, I know it's a 5 hour drive from home; but what a date that would be. If you're looking for a weekend destination; look no further. As you enjoy your meal I could be the one at the table for two with a...