Art's Pizza — Restaurant in Anderson

I order carry out from arts on Broadway often...our family loves their bread sticks and cheese! Tonight is a very different story... I called in and placed an order for 3 orders of breadsticks and fried mushrooms. They were out of mushrooms, which is fine, but the woman on the phone says, bear with me I’m new. So after she gets my information, which she found out I was already in their system...she says, we are super busy so it’s going to be an hour wait. This I thought was strange, being that usually when you call and try to place an order for breadsticks only, they say you don’t have to, just come up. So I waited, and kept thinking it was strange, so ended up going inside the restaurant 20mins early. I walked in and you could see breadsticks in the foil up where they grab them from and I still had about 5-6 people in line in front of me. Sure enough!!! Those were our breadsticks!!! I live not 3 minutes away from arts...our breadsticks were so hard and completely dried out that we could not eat them! So..waste of time, and waste of money! And a very big...

I lived in Anderson for about 9 months. I'm from Northern Indiana adjacent to Chicago so I know really good pizza. It's not easy to find phenomenal pizza this way in my opinion, but when I lived in Anderson we enjoyed the roast beef Pizza here. My daughter and I decided to go on a day ride a few days ago and she spotted the pizza joint, honestly I was going to stop and grab gyros since they are hard to come by as well this way but with a little convincing we grabbed pizza. One side was barbecue chicken pizza and the other side was roast beef. We also got an appetizer trio that included mozzarella cheese, fried ravioli and onion rings ( no photo) the barbecue side of the pizza was pretty saucy and perfect, cannot complain about the sauce on the beef side either. I only wish I could have eaten it while still in Anderson instead of waiting and bringing it home to the family. We currently reside in Fishers, so I'm certain I didn't get the full effect...

A local staple. As far as hometown pizza joints, you can't do better. My parents were kids eating at this place. There is a good reason they've been around as long as they have! As far as the menu? Close your eyes and pick. They're all pretty good dishes. Prices fair too, I'd say. Their dishes ALL have a very distinctive flavor....It tastes like....Arts! Lol, only way I know how to put it.. You'll see if you eat there. I know a few ppl that don't like it,, but they're a slim minority. Those ppl also hate puppies and sunshine too! LOL. There are a couple times I've gotten delivered dinner from there via Doordash and the food was lukewarm to cold. But I'm going to say that was doordash's fault because I'm pretty sure it was. Other than that, if you like pizza, sandwiches, pasta, etc. you couldn't do a whole lot better...