Amato's Pizza — Restaurant in Aurora

I called other pizza joints on new years day and most were closed. These guys were open and delivered! Checked on the website and found an extensive list of pizza options and other good looking food. Ordered a medium thin crust cheese pizza with garlic and extra sauce.. came out to $20.. ordered a large pan pizza with a bunch of toppings ($2.50 for each), extra sauce and well done. Total plus 20% tip came out to $80.

While that is a lot to pay for two pizzas being delivered 7mins away, everyone was 100% pleased with the pizza. It was some of the best pizza I've ever had and I get to eat pizza all the time in the city.

This place is definitely on a different level. The pan pizza was so substantial that everyone (except me) only ate one piece.. Thin cheese was demolished by the whole crew. We still have 3 pan pieces left which I am going to try and eat by myself.

I will definitely be ordering from here more often and it is now in the race for my top pizza spot with another local favorite (that was closed on new years).

Thanks again for a great dinner. Hope to try the rest of the menu...

First time trying this place and the last time. Let’s start with the service: I called to order a pizza for delivery and I was on hold for about 5 mins, not cool then delivery driver don’t deliver to your room if you are staying at hotel for whatever odd reason and they just call you for you to meet them in the lobby which defeats the purpose of delivery.

The pizza was just bad. No other way to put it. No flavor. It was just dough, cheese and meat put together in the oven. THEY put NO tomato's sauce on it, it was dry as desert sand there must be a shortage of tomatoes because this place doesn’t use IT on the pizza smh. By far one of the worst pizza in terms of flavors that I have ever tried. The dough was saggy like your eating bread and melted cheese. I can’t remember the last time I tried a pizza this bad. I wish I could just get my money back I can’t even eat the pizza so dry. Save yourself the money and try a different place you will...

Our new to us restaurant this weekend...Amatos in Naperville.

We ordered bread sticks and pizza. Bread sticks were just that.. Bread in stick form. Kind of dry I wish they had butter or something on them. No big deal.

But this pizza. That pizza was SO good. The crust was perfectly cooked; not too thick but not too thin. The cheese was layered on and the sausage and pepperoni were under the cheese, which i prefer.

I want to make a mention about the staff. They were younger, teens or maybe early 20s. But the customer service in there was above anything I expected. They were polite and friendly. They were attentive and just really seemed to care that the customers were happy. It was so far beyond what you're used to seeing, especially in a mostly carry out pizza place.

We would...