Uncle Vinny's NY Pizzeria — Restaurant in Broken Arrow

Pizza Paradise Found at Uncle Vinny's Pizzeria!

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

From the moment you step into Uncle Vinny's Pizzeria in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, you are swept up in a symphony of delicious scents and incredible hospitality. It's a place where pizza dreams are born and realized, where a love for the classic Italian dish is palpified into a stunning reality. Their single slice 'Build Your Own' pizzas are nothing short of remarkable, allowing you to embark on a culinary adventure that is both customizable and unforgettable.

The sheer variety of topping choices at Uncle Vinny's is mind-boggling. From the luscious sun-ripened tomatoes to the piquant locally-sourced sausage, each ingredient adds a new dimension of flavor. The mozzarella, so creamy it's almost dreamy, strings delightfully with every bite, while the basil leaves add a punch of freshness that takes you right to the heart of Naples. And who could forget the multitude of other options? Exotic mushrooms, kalamata olives, roasted garlic, gourmet meats - every selection only serves to enhance the depth and complexity of your personal pizza masterpiece.

Service at Uncle Vinny's is just as impressive. The staff, cheerful and personable, exudes genuine warmth that enhances the overall dining experience. Their attention to detail is evident in every interaction - from the helpful suggestions offered when you're torn between topping choices, to the skillful manner in which they ensure each dish is delivered in perfect order. You never have to wait long for your mouth-watering creation to arrive, yet it's evident that no shortcuts have been taken in the kitchen. The quick, efficient service is a testament to Uncle Vinny's commitment to delivering top-notch cuisine without compromising on quality.

Every visit to Uncle Vinny's is a gastronomic joyride. It's not just about the pizza - it's about the unique experience, the care put into each slice, and the passionate team that brings it all together. Uncle Vinny's is not just a pizzeria, it's a slice of heaven for pizza lovers. For those yet to visit, it's a culinary adventure waiting to be...

Alright y'all I REALLY WANTED to love their food. I had high expectations based on all of the positive reviews I saw in this group. Even with the high expectations, I wasn't expecting perfection. I was cautiously optimistic. Here's what we got and what we thought:

Pepperoni Slice: the crust was soft and this was even after I added it to my oven at 400 degrees for 6 minutes to give it more crisp. It was under seasoned in general. I added garlic powder and red pepper flakes (as I do to all pizza) and it still was a bit bland and chewy.

Chicken and Cheese Calzone: I was so excited to see they make calzones. It's one of the things I miss most about NYC (along with chicken parm heroes) but, this was the biggest disappointment of the night. The "grilled chicken" was white and I mean whiter than the ricotta cheese and mozzarella. This means it was most likely not grilled. It looked either boiled or frozen. Everything about this calzone was bland. There was ZERO seasoning. No flavor AT ALL. Thankfully the side of sauce helped with that. Also the dough was mushy and yes, I reheated it with the hopes of it crisping up a bit but the inside of the dough was raw.

Garlic Knots: These were not knots. They were more like breadsticks from Olive Garden. They were dry and lacked seasoning and barely had any garlic. Traditionally garlic knots have fresh garlic and olive oil on them, are crispy on the outside and soft on the inside and they are more like bites. This was not that.

Please know, I was routing for this place. I spent my entire life (born, raised) in NYC until 3 years ago and I miss those flavors. When I see ppl recommend NYC style places I have high hopes but I am not unrealistic about it. I can appreciate different pizza for what it is but when they call them selves NYC pizza, I have something very specific come to mind. Unfortunately, we will not...

Today’s Quiz. What is a Hot Stinger? a.) a surface to air missile. b) a serrano pepper, or c.) a Kia automobile. Actually, it doesn’t really matter; Uncle Vinny’s doesn’t have any of those anyway. (Read on for the correct answer.)

A Stromboli for me today! More specifically a NY style Stromboli vs. an original Mike’s Burger Royal (Spokane, WA) style Stromboli. Uncle Vinny’s Stromboli is a tasty, dense, meaty, pizza style sandwich; slightly different than their calzone. The stromboli came with two small cups of excellent seasoned tomato dipping sauce. A pleasant change up for lunch this week.

My wife had one of her favorites, spaghetti and meatball(s). A big pan of spaghetti and Vinny’s tasty tomato sauce with a big Q ball sized meat ball floating on top. A pizza crust bread roll on the side. For me, spaghetti is one of the most boring meals on earth. I almost fell asleep just looking at it. But she loved it.

Uncle Vinny’s offers pizza by the slice, with your choice of toppings. A bargain. They are big slices. Hot Oil is prominently displayed on the menu board, a popular condiment here. Great for dipping or spicing up the whole pizza. And check out those peperoni rolls and the pastry display case! Yeah buddy!

This is a neat, cozy, restaurant with great friendly service. Fair prices and generous servings. Judging from the weathered sign out front Uncle Vinny’s has been around for years. A Broken Arrow favorite with dedicated customers.

The answer is: b.) A hot stinger is a serrano pepper. Sometimes several whole serrano peppers are placed on top of, and baked with the pizza to give it a spicy kick. (A topping listed on the menu at Uncle Vinny’s, but they...