Sarah's Pizza — Restaurant in Brookville

What a horrible experience,I ordered a sub with extra meat and Xtra onions ,no peppers! And cheese sticks. The meat was frozen in the middle and to top it off they were fake patties, there was no mushrooms or onions on the sub at which I payed extra for extra.When calling to correct matters with management he argued that the 🌶 s were green ,I told him the colour didn't matter I did not order them,he argued that there was plenty of mushrooms and onions. NOT 1 folks! To end with no solution the manager then took and accused me of having a speech impediment by saying I threatened him .Clean out your ears sir or atleast don't try to redeem yourself by correlation of a made up story.So therefore my final conclusion is 0 stars! Not even on the map unless you need a quick fix for your fury family friend,a sort of replacement for Purina or Alpo..Management handled things as if selling 10 cent 🍋 lemonade...The Holiday Inn express where I am staying said the owner is a known drug addiction and the place use to be great but has taken an unfortunate turn, I'd...

Had probably the most expensive pizza on Sunday that I've ever had. An 18 inch pizza from Sarah's in Brookville that ended up costing me $46. Yep, $46 for 1 pizza. Here's why. The pizza actually came to $22.79. I gave a tip, bringing the total to $26. Maybe not a great tip, but not bad. Here's the kicker. They called me about an hour after we got the pizza claiming that I had paid them with a bad $20 and wanted me to give them another $20 to cover it. They didn't bother to call the police to report the bad bill. I have no way to determine if the bill actually came from me. The way they presented this to me I felt pretty backed into a corner. Rather than pushing back, I caved, which probably wasn't one of my smarter moves. So, $46 pizza. Now, on the other side of the coin, I'd have to say that Sarah's has lost a customer. I ended up doing what Sarah's should have done by calling the police about this myself. You might want to pass this along to help keep others from falling into the same trap. This is not a respectable...

Our latest mission in Brookville, OH, has led to a critical discovery: Sarah’s Pizza, a 25-year cornerstone of the local community. To test their mettle, we ordered their XL 18-inch all-meat pizza—a bold choice, but one that paid off spectacularly. This was no ordinary pie. It was a starship of flavor, loaded with toppings in quantities that could sustain a small crew. No rations were spared.

The 18-inch XL is a marvel, easily large enough to feed several adults, with leftovers that promise to extend the mission into tomorrow. Each slice was a tactical masterpiece, and their commitment to quality is nothing short of commendable.

Sarah’s Pizza has officially been added to our list of essential local resources, ensuring future expeditions will always be well-fueled. For those stationed in the area, this is a prime recommendation....