MANGIA ITALIANO — Restaurant in Cabo Rojo

I ordered two Margherita pizzas to go, which were listed as medium, but they felt more like personal sized pizzas. For the price, the size was definitely underwhelming.

As for the taste, it was just okay, nothing memorable. I noticed another reviewer compared it to NY style pizza, but if that's the case, it reminded me more of the cheap $1 slices you used to find in NYC before the pandemic. It's not the kind of quality you expect when someone says “good NY pizza.” I understand taste is subjective, but in my opinion, this wasn’t it.

I was hungry, so I ate mine, but my wife barely touched hers and ended up throwing it out. I think a better dough could have improved the overall flavor and texture.

In short: average pizza at best, and not something I’d go out of my way to order again.

Thanks for responding. Just to clarify—my review wasn’t meant as a personal jab. I simply shared my honest opinion about the food. I asked the person taking my order how many slices came with it, and they told me it was about a medium, which shaped my expectations.

Fresh ingredients are great, but they don’t automatically mean the pizza will taste amazing. I specifically mentioned the dough because I thought it could have been better. NYC tap water is known to help with dough quality, and I felt that difference.

A 4.9-star rating is impressive, but no place is perfect every day. Maybe it just wasn’t your best day. Again, nothing personal—just...

Mangia Italiano: A Taste of Naples in Cabo Rojo Nestled in Joyuda Cabo Rojo, Puerto Rico, Mangia Italiano is a culinary gem that transports diners straight to the bustling trattorias of Naples. From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with warm hospitality and the enticing aroma of authentic Italian cuisine. Our server, Bri, was an absolute delight. Her friendly demeanor, attentiveness, and knowledge of the menu truly enhanced our dining experience. She was happy to offer recommendations and ensured we had everything we needed to enjoy our meal to the fullest. The food was nothing short of exceptional. Each dish was prepared with fresh, high-quality ingredients and bursting with flavor. The pasta was cooked to perfection, the sauces were rich and savory, and the portions were generous. We especially enjoyed the pizza de la nonna its a testament to the chef's expertise in Neapolitan cuisine. Mangia Italiano offers a delightful ambiance, with its charming decor and lively atmosphere. Whether you're seeking a romantic dinner for two or a fun gathering with friends and family, this restaurant provides the perfect setting. Overall, our experience at Mangia Italiano was outstanding. The combination of delicious food, impeccable service from Bri, and inviting atmosphere makes this a must-visit for anyone seeking an authentic taste of Italy in Cabo Rojo. We highly recommend it and can't...

Mangia Italiano is a true hidden gem in Cabo Rojo! From the moment we stepped in, we were charmed by its cozy and intimate atmosphere. The warm lighting and rustic decor instantly transported us to a quaint village in Italy.

The menu, though modest in size, offers an array of authentic Italian dishes that are simply delightful. We started with the fried ravioli , which was perfectly crisp and topped with fresh, flavorful ingredients. The homemade pasta was the highlight of our meal; the was creamy and rich, while the pizzas was a delightful blend of savory flavors and melt-in-your-mouth textures.

The service was impeccable. Our waiter was attentive and knowledgeable, offering excellent wine pairings that complemented our meals beautifully. Despite being a small establishment, the staff made us feel like honored guests, adding a personal touch to our dining experience.

Mangia Italiano is a must-visit for anyone craving authentic Italian cuisine in a cozy, welcoming setting. We’ll definitely be...