The Shed Pizzeria — Restaurant in Carlisle

I’ve been all over the U.S. thanks to my military service, and along the way, I’ve tried more kinds of pizza than I can count — big city staples, small-town favorites, the works. But The Shed Pizzeria? This place blew me away.

The first thing that stood out was the sauce. It’s not that overly sweet stuff a lot of places use — this is rich, savory, and packed with flavor. You can tell they care about what they’re doing here. The ingredients are top-notch too. Everything tasted fresh and high quality — nothing greasy or bland. The flavors actually come through in every bite.

And that crust... man. The brick oven cooking really makes a difference. It’s got that perfect light crunch on the outside, but inside it’s airy, soft, and full of flavor. I didn’t even leave the crust behind like I usually do — it was that good.

After trying pizza all over the country, I can honestly say this is the best I’ve had. No gimmicks, no shortcuts — just really, really good pizza made right. If you're anywhere near this place, go try it. You...

Excellent, locally owned restaurant, with an owner who is not only on site, but is also fully engaged in creating amazing pizzas and salads. Upon entering, the smell of pizza magic drew us in. We started with a salad of romaine lettuce and slivers of Parmesan, dressed in a delicious vinaigrette. The pizza was excellent, with the slightly charred spots on the crispy, yet tender crust that prove it was cooked correctly in a pizza oven. The service was excellent, and the young servers didn’t stop taking care of our needs. Amazingly enough, not one had a cell phone in hand, unlike so many other places where customer service takes second place to social media.

Great prices—we will stop again if we come this...

Absolutely floored to know there is a Pizzeria so close to home that is knocking the walls down with some AMAZING brick oven style pizza!! Just wow!

We would place The Shed on the same level as Deluca’s and SQZBX in Hot Springs!

Can not say enough about how great their pizza was tonight..

Wonderful simple decor, clean and cozy feel, Ninja Turtle Style cheese pull on everything, and the Parmesan vinaigrette was to die for….

Do yourself a favor and RUN to grab you some...