Goodfellas Pizza — Restaurant in City of Amsterdam

That's not a Calzone, now this, is a Calzone.

Ordered over the phone a couple hours ahead of time, putting in for a dozen Garlic Knots, a "small" salad with House Italian, and a Fried Calzone with Onion, Mushroom and Peppers. All together coming to a very acceptable price tag of a little over $24.00.

When I got home and opened it all up I was astounded by the sheer size of the Calzone, it was like they took a medium pizza and just folded it in half. Woof, that was a lot of cheese. Sadly I did go with the fried option, because I though that'd make the dough crispy, but instead it had a texture more inline with carnival fried dough. The Garlic Knots were, stupendous, lightly crunchy with a good soaking in the garlic butter to give them rich flavor. Probably my favorite part of the meal. As for the salad, well, I don't know if it was the house Italian or what, but the salad was strangely sour. The dressing also seemed at first brush to have zero flavor, just an extremely simple olive oil and vinegar blend with a few spices, so I was left befuddled as to why it was as off-putting as it was. Also, they weren't kidding when they listed the "small" salad as serving for 2-3, can't imagine what the large looks like.

All in all this meal was very very filling for a very reasonable price, the people I did interact with were friendly (or adorable in the cashier's case), but the lack of crunch from the Calzone and the sour salad leaves me subtracting a star. Still, a great local joint that easily beats out the...

What a terrible experience. First time ordering. Thought why not try it out. First they tell me 35-40 mins wait to pickup. No biggie. We get there and are told to wait another 15-20mins. Again no big deal. Get our order go home and it's wrong. I ordered 2 Italian subs with mayo, order of chicken fingers and a steak sub. I got my order of chicken fingers, steak sub w/ chips (should've been fries). And the biggest let down 2 Italian WRAPS. I called them to let them know and they tell me fries don't come with steak subs although that's what their website says. And that my ticket says wraps not subs. Not going to argue I just say that's fine I'll just never order from there again. Go to eat my wrap that I have no choice but to eat and it has jalapeno peppers on it. I NEVER asked for jalapeno peppers. It's obvious my order was messed up. Thanks for selling me food I can't eat. Needless to say we...

This place needs some "girl power", not grill, but girl. Like I'm being brought this delicious saucy meatball sandwich and no napkins. My friend gets a salad and no dressing. Oh, we should have known and gotten napkins at the front desk. My friend has to go to the front desk and ask for dressing. There were all dudes running the show here, and the details of consumer needs are missing. As we leave, my friend complimented the food, it was great. He thought he heard a grunt. Gals would have said "thank you"...