Scarsdale Pastry Center — Restaurant in City of New Rochelle

This is not the place to get an on theme cake. What a disappointment this bakery is. They do not have professional cake decorators. I went in and was assured that they would execute a one tier cake that was Toy Story theme. I asked for just clouds and a sign that said “A BOY STORY” clearly what was given to me was not even remotely close to the example photo I emailed them and showed them in person the day I ordered the cake. They did remove the letter “s” after my request and they offered to refund the money and they would keep the cake.

Who in their right mind on the day of an event would walk away empty handed when they need a cake for a party. I was tempted to take my money back and leave them their came, however then I’d be left with no cake on the day of my God Son’s baby shower.

All in all, this place has cute little cookies and pastries, but does not have expertise cake decorators. Would not recommend for any big...

Honestly, the rainbow cookies have too much extract and they're a bit stiff, and very sweet. Just my opinion, seems most people would disagree with me. Also, though the cookie is right on the sarah bernhardts, the filling is not. I had these cookies in Iceland and drove 2 hours today to this bakery because they're one of the only places that makes them, but was disappointed. If you're ever in Reykjavik, look for these cookies at almost any little cafe and do a little comparison for yourself. Totally different. That being said, they ARE good cookies - very rich, but they're just not the same. And way smaller. The black and white cookie, now that was good. Fluffy, unique texture with the perfect icing. And the raspberry mousse cake was also beautiful in flavor and in appearance, the tartness of the fruit was not drowned out by sweetness. Definitely recommend this cake. Nice experience overall and happy to try a new...

I ordered a sheet cake for 50 people from Scarsdale Pastry Center. I had had their pastries before - which are delicious - but never their cakes so I wasn’t sure what to expect. The woman who took my order was very helpful describing to me what flavor combinations would go well together. I ended up choosing a vanilla cake with fudge filling and a vanilla buttercream frosting. I had told her what I had wanted written on the cake. She asked if the baker could decorate the cake and I said sure but otherwise gave no direction. I was absolutely blown away by what they put together! Firstly the cake was absolutely delicious! The fudge filling was so light and creamy and the cake itself was so fluffy. The vanilla buttercream was also very light which is exactly what I had wanted. The decorations were more than I ever imagined. Overall I had an amazing experience and will definitely be ordering...