Little Mac's Pizzeria — Restaurant in City of Syracuse

...and yet another UPDATE: 8/5/23: I never did call the owner as he requested because I'm all for giving any place another chance on my own and at my own pace. Tonight I ordered a Veggie Pizza and mild wings and asked for delivery. This time the guy on the other end of the phone taking my order was a lot more attentive and helpful. My pizza was delivered hot and delicious, as were the wings. Again, the crust was thin and crispy just how I like it. The delivery guy was very nice too. I'm chalking up my last experience to just bad timing. Damn, their pizza is sooooo good!!!!!!!!

UPDATE: I enjoyed the food so much when I wrote my original review that I called to place an order late yesterday afternoon and requested delivery this time. A not-so-nice person answered the phone and asked if I'd hold and when I said yes he put the phone down and never picked the phone back up. I waited 3 minutes and only heard kitchen sounds. That's just bad business so I hung up and ordered from another local pizza place. Sure the food is good here but apparently the service is hit or miss?

ORIGINAL REVIEW: I remember when this pizzeria was near Henninger High School but I never tried their pizza even though I always heard good things about it. The pizzeria moved much closer to my home awhile back but I still never had tried it. Finally, yesterday I tried it and boy, was I sorry I hadnt tried it sooner. First, I called and ordered to have pizza ready for pickup at a certain time and not only was it ready, but it was hot and smelled delicious. Next, they helped me to my car with my order which was so nice and unexpected! Now for the food. I had guests and we all agreed that the pizza had very good flavor and wasn't swimming with tomato sauce. The sausage was mild and tasty and reminded me of the sausage Angotti uses on their pizza except there was way more sausage on this pizza. The mushrooms were fresh and not canned which was a huge plus in our book. My favorite thing about the pizza was that the crust was crispy. Eureka!! Finally, a pizzeria that doesn't make soggy crusts and I didn't even have to ask for them to crisp it up (which most places ignore anyway). The breaded wings were very meaty and crispy and just outright delicious. The wings were probably the best I've had in a very long time. If I had one complaint it would probably be that I couldn't order online, but it's a very minor complaint. The guy behind the counter said they're still old-fashioned and hey, if your food is that good, then you have every...

Just moved to the area from Baldwinsville, so my fiance and I are on the hunt for the best New York style pizza in the area. This place had great reviews, so we figured, why not?

For starters, $20(+) for a large pizza was a little more than I was expecting, but not a big deal. Then they told us it would take about an hour -- again, no worries, it was a Saturday night.

Fast forward an hour and a half and I gave a call just to see if it was on its way. To my surprise, apparently the driver had tried to deliver a bit before my call and we were told that the driver called multiple times and was knocking, but I never received a call and we're in an apartment building. Not sure why the shop didn't give us a call after the driver called them to let them know we didn't answer, but they didn't.

Anyways, they said they would send the driver back out and said apparently he had the wrong number. About an hour and forty-five minutes after ordering, it finally shows. It's warm, enough, but the cheese has started to get firm and you can just tell that it's no longer fresh.

All this to say, the pizza ended up tasting like roller rink pizza. Like something you would get at a baseball game or a big birthday party for a child. Nearly 2 hours and $20 later and the pizza ended up being just... serviceable. Not great, not horrible, but just ok.

Pretty...

We regularly order from Little Mac’s typically a large 2 topping and 20 wings that comes to around $50 today on a Wednesday we ordered a medium 2 topping pizza and 20 wings they advertise a large cheese and 20 wings to be $35. I arrived to a total of $51 and no justification by staff other than their online menus are inaccurate and their handwritten one in the shop is correct.

If you’re ordering be sure to ask for your total over the phone and always bring cash their credit card up charge is...