Brick Oven Pizza — Restaurant in City of Watertown

This review is long overdue. My first and only time visiting was sometime shortly after the location on Public Square opened. Our order was just two cheese pizzas. When I walked in, I was greeted by the annoying bird chirping sound and a soundbar connected to the TV blasting in my ear, barely able to hear anything else. I was inside for maybe 3 minutes to get our pizzas. When I walked out, I gave them to my wife to hold onto for the ride home. After getting home, I got out and took them from her. My wife's pants were covered in grease. Not just a small spot, but soaked in a big area. We went inside, she got changed and threw them out because there was no saving them with the amount of grease. While she was getting changed, I looked at the pizzas. They were drenched in oil. So much, it was pooled up on both pizzas. Even the box was soaked like it was just in water. Crust was good but pizza itself wasn't great. We decided not to...

Scotty's NYP is no question one of the best pizza places I've been to in the area! From the perfect balance of flavors to the crispy crust, every bite is delicious. Their gluten-free cauliflower crust pizza is a game changer; my sister and I both agree it’s the best we’ve had. Plus, they use locally sourced toppings, like cheese and pepperoni, which really elevate the whole experience.

What makes Scotty's even more special is the owner. He’s not only kind and generous but also gives back to the community by donating their extra slices to the homeless. It’s a rare find when a place cares this much, and it makes the pizza taste even better knowing they have such a big heart. Highly recommend and we will be a...

I wish I could say I even tried the food. We tried ordering TWICE and were left hungry and waiting and forced to come up with an alternative plan both times. One time we tried ordering through UberEats, and while the owner texted us about making it up to us, they never did. First I tried contacting them directly about the compensation they offered us. No response. Then we tried ordering again today through DoorDash, and our order was accepted and apparently also prepared. They finished the order on DoorDash but our food never arrived and we even called multiple times but no one picked up. Will not be ordering again as we gave them two chances and were...