Montegrillo Cucina Italiana Collingswood — Restaurant in Collingswood

Delicious food with great service, clean, comfortable, nice atmosphere. Loved it! Our server was very attentive and friendly and made our first experience here a memorable one. The Antipasto Rustica was a terrific balance of roasted red peppers, artichokes, marinated eggplant, olives, salami, soppresata ham, Italian cheeses, tuna, and a scrumptious bruschetta. We shared it for 2, but it could have been a whole meal for one. We tried a slice of Grandma's that was very tasty with the cheese on bottom and tomato sauce on top plus fresh basil, and also a slice of classic Sicilian (the crust was delicious: soft but not undercooked on the inside and toasty but not too hard on the outside). My favorite was the eggplant Parm sandwich, served open with thin slices of lightly fried eggplant, smooth tomato sauce, and melted mozzarella on toasty Italian bread. Ahh, just like Nanna's. We're...

Nice people, clean establishment, but perhaps the most middling Sicilian pie I’ve received for $26. Crust is strangely dry, almost feels like it’s been frozen. Same goes for the toppings, very dehydrated all around. Sauce a bit sweet for my liking, but that’s more of a me thing.

It’s a shame Collingswood doesn’t have any remarkable pizza in its downtown. I’d much rather spend the extra few dollars and drive the extra 10 minutes for Genova or Bruno’s.

I’m hoping the quality improves; having a good pizzeria nearby is a valuable thing I took for granted. Don’t get it twisted, I’m not revolted, this food is fine. It’s passable in the same way bowling alley pizza is passable. It harkens back to classroom pizza party quality.

For its current price point, I don’t think I’m giving Montegrillo another shot for a...

We really wanted to love this place since Colls we feel is totally lacking a great pizzeria. The people are super nice and the place is nice and clean. First time we ordered we wanted to try a bunch of things. I did get plain fries instead of the mozzarella fries I ordered, so that was a bummer. The chicken cheesesteak would’ve been better if the cheese was helpful the steak and not just on the bottom. But anyway we decided to order again but delivery this time. Idk what the process is for picking up an order and hand off but we got someone else’s order. So still not mozzarella cheese fries!! We were hungry so we ate what came which was not really anything we would order. The cheesesteak appeared to have dried hardish onions on it just like the pizza. Super disappointing. Maybe over time things...