Sammy's New York Bagels — Restaurant in Columbus

I grew up in Columbus, Ohio and had a Sammy’s bagel every week throughout the mid to late 90s. My mom was obsessed with them (the only food item she’s ever truly loved). We moved to Florida in ‘98 and my mom has been to dozens and dozens of bagel shops throughout the state and has never found one with the quality and taste of Sammy’s. She still brings them up whenever we’re reminiscing and she’s not one that cares much food (unlike me). Cut to today: her birthday is coming up and I wanted to do something special for her by having Sammy’s shipped down here. I wasn’t sure it was doable so I reached out and received a reply from Audra. First of all, whoever owns Sammy’s, give this woman a RAISE! She is so sweet and delightful and she went out of her way to go by the post office and get a quote for me on shipping. She made the whole thing happen and cared about making my mom’s birthday a success. She clearly loves her job and is the perfect person to represent the company. I give six stars to Audra, even though it will only allow me to give five. ORDER SAMMY’S BAGELS AND ASK FOR AUDRA! You won’t...

I've been meaning to give this place a try for a long time, and finally took the plunge over the weekend. Regretting now that I waited so long! The bagels were wonderful, but I absolutely loved the baked goods. Cinnamon roll was delicious, and the muffins are ridiculous! They are huge! Danish are also very tasty. I put in an order for Christmas Eve the very next day...love the free delivery! It was nicely packaged and waiting on my porch for me when I woke up in the morning. Very easy...

Update:

They appear to have sorted out their delivery issues, so I'm happy to change my 2-star rating to a 5-star rating. They are truly delicious bagels.

Original review:

Usually the best bagels in town, but their delivery to Cup O Joe in Clintonville has become unreliable. It's less and less common that they've delivered on time, and sometimes they...