Peanut's Ice Cream and Cookie Dough — Restaurant in Eagle River

The scoops were small and the prices were high. I was appalled that my wife and I were charged an extra $2.00 EACH because we ordered two different flavors of ice cream in the same dish. I suppose making their money off of the tourists they don't care about gouging you as they probably don't care if you come back or not. I recommend finding a different place for your ice cream fix. The building is cutesy but the interior decoration is just kind of blah. I have since been contacted by the owner offering a refund for the extra charges if I could produce a receipt. The problem being I was never offered or received a receipt. I stand by my...

It’s not that I don’t like ice cream…I just usually couldn’t care less about ice cream. Enter Peanuts and their apocalyptically delicious flavor ELECTRIC WATERMELON (thunder, lightening!).

I bought and consumed an entire pint. First pint of ice cream I’ve eaten in my life…and I’m a middle-aged dad. Tonight though, because I’ve flown home (tragically far) from Eagle River, I can’t have any more Electric Watermelon. Let the weeping begin.

Let my tears of sorrow be your guide. Get to...

Carries Chocolate Shoppe Premium ice cream. The Zanzibar dark chocolate is the best chocolate ice cream in the world.

But I wish they would begin to carry more alternatives. Such as Choc. Shoppe oat milk Mint Oreo, or Lemon Italian ice. They do have Blue Moon oat which is kinda a kids flavor as their only vegan or lactose intolerant option. They have 40 flavors but a few more of the 14 Choc Shoppe nondairy for the 20% of lactose intolerant...