Sicilia Pizza Marietta — Restaurant in East Donegal Township

One week later... We thought we would give it another try....boy did they loose good customers! We thought we would try ordering online,thinking how can they mess up when it is printed out for them. 3 of 4 subs were not made as asked. When I call in..they knew already because I guess they figured out they packaged up two orders wrong..then I proceed to tell him about the other two subs...he took the information said we can come pick up the subs. I asked if they deliver, he took the address, we thought everything was taken care of..NOPE..10 mins later I get a call back...disagreeing with me about the other 2 subs, I pass the phone to the person who ordered and picked up the order and he is disagreeing with him..voices are getting raised...his order was completely wrong so he is hungry and upset and getting yelled at because they messed up...this is NOT how your treat your customers! Subs WERE NEVER DELIVERED AS I WAS TOLD THEY WOULD BE and they will no longer be getting our money...such a shame we REALLY enjoyed them when they first opened...now have to find another place..so sad... When first opened FIVE STARS! I wouldn't stop raving about it, wanted a sub for every meal....SO DELICIOUS....Past few times not too impressed....TODAY...very skimpy and not made as asked...VERY...

So you have Italians speak no English and Mexican Speak clear English, we sat down to check out, no menus on Tables, No one shows a waiter, so we walk up order pizza, we ordered a large buffalo chicken pizza, and Guy offers us a 2 slice of pizza and one drink for $10 we don’t understand that said no, and asked for large pizza, waited about 20 minutes, came out sure enough we paid for buffalo chicken pizza and got a Normal cheese pizza, asked if they make are pizza we requested was told 20 minutes and we said no not worth are 1 hour lunch, I wasn’t the best pizza in town, it tasted differently odd, no music, You have Italians speaking there language and Mexican speaking there language it sounds weird, the one guy sat on his computer most of the time, I walked up to the guy asking if they served real Italy food and he just give me the menu, I wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone, 0-5 on food! Paper plates shows your weak on...

My husband brought me here and said I had to try this place. Let me tell you…..I love and I mean love food. When eating you have to be able to enjoy the food as well as the experience. Tasting the food with that much flavor and to feel the flavor explosion is like listening to a symphony for the first time. Their homemade salsa tastes the way it was meant to taste. It’s bursts with delicious flavor and is never bland. I have had their cheeseburger subs and their shrimp quesadilla. I always get the extra salsa. This family appreciates the value of great (not good) great tasting food. When you get the approval of my Italian family you will most definitely get the approval of my Irish/ Scottish family. Hands down best place to eat ever.

Oh try the cannolis....